whose argument is right sachin or chappel?

Answer 1

SACHIN TENDULKAR

Answer 2

My god....this is amazing!! For once all the Indian fans arent blaming Chappell! Well done for realizing guys, I feel sorry for you in that the politics in cricket there has robbed you of a great coach.

Chappell is right, and Tendulkars argument highlights one of the major problems in Indian cricket.

It seems as though a lot of the Indian players cannot accept criticism at all. I think they are too used to having people around them who would tell them they were going great no matter how they performed. When Chappell came in he rocked the boat by telling these guys the truth on how they were performing and they did not like this because they rightfully felt their position was under place, which it should be if they are not performing.

Tendulkar has been one of the main culprits when it comes to a lack of performance in recent times - perhaps his argument was one of a great player whose skills are in decline and does not want to acknowledge the end is near.

Answer 3

Both of thier arguments are right. It presents correct picture of the situation, personally and team wise. We need both peices to understand complete situation.

But the timing by Greg and the platform Sachin used is incorrect.

These are my observations :

1. Tendulkar should have chosen to talk or present his/teams opinion directly to BCCI or selectors.

2. Greg should not have reacted immediately. He should have waited till he met BCCI and presented his views of the debacle.

3. By reacting immediately to Sachin's remark and presenting his resignation, Greg invariably showed that there was surely some truth to what Sachin said.

Our loss : Now since Gregs views were not completely heard by BCCI we will never (maybe) know what else was going on in the team. Which will be a big blow, considering the new coach or selectors cannot make more accurate decisions.

Some of those internal things may never come out.

Team will still sulk in groupism until some seniors leave the team.

Answer 4

Chappel

Answer 5

Chappel is professional n obviously Indian mentality cant digest his medhology..
Sachin never won a match in crisis...n his game for last 3 years really sucks.... he should be sacked like Ganguly

Answer 6

Greg Chappell.

Answer 7

Sachin is throughly wromg , but Chappel has a few correct points

Answer 8

Sachin is wrong and he should retire ...his reflexes are not what they used to be.He should go in for what hes spendin his time doing like commercials and all that crap ....he should certainly stay away from harbhajan,sehwag,kumble,ganguly and the gang .....Chappel was a very respected cricketer and a great coach and he had good intentions for the team when he came in 2005 but indian cricket politics did not allow him to function.illinformed and poor media reporting in india is greatly responsible for the present state of affairs ..they dont know their priorities and dont ask the right questions !!!!

Answer 9

I strongly feel that Chappel is right. A Coach has every right to point out mistakes or short comings of any player, whoever great he is and no player should feel bad about it.

Answer 10

sachin tendulkar

Answer 11

sachin