does quota needs to be implemented?

Answer 1

Don’t you think we had enough of this reservation in the Indian Politics that now every one here is asking about it, as an Indian I sometime feels ashamed when people around the world ask "What This Bloody Reservation Is All About?" We all know it is only a political game of these petty politicians who otherwise have not only grown so old with both their legs hanging in grave but they are good for nothing. So my dear friend I hope this will be the last question in this regard. Hell with this reservation which has spoiled the whole nation. Article 14 of the Constitution talks of equality but Articles 15, 16 17... Brings in the importance of reservation just to bring unequal to the meet the equals. How long we will support such a view as now those unequal have already passed ahead of equals but still because of political reasons the Govt. of India & these politicians want to continue this reservation issue so their kitchen stoves remain burning otherwise who will care about them & they will be get unemployed, begging alms on street.

Answer 2

Certainly not.

The quota system has done enough damage.. leave alone uplifting the backward classes.

It is just another chapter of "Vote Bank" politics.

On the contrary the government should evaluate the success of quotas till now, which has been negligible anyways.

Rather than going all out in implementing quotas the authorities and so called leaders should channelize energy and commitment towards providing better quality education and create more employment opportunities for the economically backward citizens of this country.

Its not quota but progressive reforms with ample opportunities and good infrastructure that will ensure well being of this country and its citizens.

Answer 3

The Quota system stands against the very principles that we fought freedom for - Equality. Reservation must be enforced for those people who cannot afford education. But the lack of a system like social security number (USA) prevents us from tracking income. Unless we come up with a fool-proof system to do the same, implementing the quota system would be a blunder.

Answer 4

Now there is not much difference between those who need quota and those who doesn't need them, so i think there is no need for quota to be implemented. Unlike the earlier days when low caste were far lower than the nornals, they needed some quota to develope but now since they r also developed as others, there is no need for quota.

Answer 5

Reservation is no doubt an effective tool for the amelioration of the lots of SC/ST. Many of the SCs, at least in the Southern States have been benefited. By virtue of reservation, many of them could get good education and come to occupy important positions. This may not be the case among the large chunk of the class in majority of the States. I think we should not grumble this special treatment to them.

As regards the reservation to OBCs, I have a different opinion. The recent SC judgement has stayed the operation of reservation in educational institutional institutions, on the ground that the statistics regarding the OBCs after 1931 census is not available with the Government. I am against reservation for this category, for the simple reason that the so called OBCs have been the ruling class, holding important political offices. When they are in a position to influence the course of the polity and decision making, how can we categorise them as backward classes. Introduction of reservation to these classes is only a measure of their influence and power in the society and not because of their backwardness. On the other hand, the SCs and STs, despite the benefit that had accrued on them, due to reservation, are still vulnerable and suffer ill-treatment in the society.

I am prepared to concede reservation to even the OBC and for other categories, on two conditions:-

Firstly, the exclusion of the creamy layer from the so called OBCs from the purview of reservation should be agreed to;

Secondly, there should be a time limit for the reservation regime to operate. It cannot be perpetual spoil system. We must graduate from the reservation regime to an egalitarian regime of meritocracy, after the expiry of the strict time frame.

Answer 6

Quota is not a mean to help SC or BC people. Its only a mean to deviate from their responsibilities. If minister really care about the people they must provide better and carrier oriented education. Its really pathetic to see the standard of the school and there are lot of school which don't have proper facility. In order to surface many big problem they are giving importance to small things like reservation.

Answer 7

No ! Even presently too, because of commercialising the education and also with the existing reservations, brilliant deserving scholars do not get admission to right discipline. Not only this more than 50% production are not even average knowledgeable.

Education beyond 10th stander has to be regulated purely on meritorious performances and not on basis of cast, category and financial capability.

Answer 8

According to me there should be a quota for economicaly backward people and not on basis of caste.
While suggesting reservations Mr. Ambedkar himself had expressed his concerns that politicians may misuse it in future thats why he wanted reservations only for 10 years.

Answer 9

The Central and all State Governments provided reservations in employment/jobs and educational institutions to members of the Scheduled Castes/Tribes and OBCs; in addition to lot of other facilities: FREE houses, house sites, agricultural lands, seeds, fertilizers, occupational equipments, dresses & uniforms, books, hostels, monthly expenses, etc. They can avail of it so long as they are SCs STs & OBCs (Hindu).

The very important & much necessary condition of remaining SC, ST, OBC is to remain a Hindu in Hinduism. Hinduism is not a religion. It is a culture, custom, tradition, way of Hindus' lives in Hindustan (India). It is claimed as such by all the well known Hindu priests, scholars, intellectuals, books, scripts, the Ruling Party BJP & Shiv Sena, Bajrang Dal, the Indian & International strongest Hindu organisations RSS & VHP, etc.

The SCs, STs, OBCs are much degraded & lower viewed, humiliated & insulted in Hinduism which practises casteism based inequality. The moment they embrace a religion and convert to Islam or Christianity, they lose all Govt. facilities though their financial and social condition will remain the same. They have to pay such big price for coming out of Hinduism; hence mostly prefer to remain in Hinduism for such financial benefits.

The moment, the Govt. withdraws these facilities/subsidies and reservations, millions and millions of SCs, STs & OBCs will jump out of Hinduism and embrace a religion Christianity or Islam. Hence learned intellectual Hindus in power always continue such facilities to SCs, STs & OBCs to keep them in Hinduism suffering all sort of inequalities, inhumanities, insults, humiliations,etc.

Answer 10

noooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo
we all are equal...equal..equal...i don't agree with this bloody quota system...