Athens vs. Sparta? Which city-state was better? What was the role of men in these two city-states?

Question

We have a upcoming debate and I have to know which city-state was better and the roles of men, which includes the EDUCATION, JOBS, and RIGHTS FOR MEN. PLEASE HELP!

Answer 1

sparta was a miltary nation athens was more complex and 300 is nowhere near the truth only on fact and thats that it was 300 spartans against persain thats it

Answer 2

Sparta and Athens, the two most powerful cities of Hellas, did not have much in common. The Athenians attempted to develop their artistic and intellectual capabilities, while Sparta remained isolated from the rest of Hellas, without art or literature, without beautiful buildings, without any development of their social and political traditions. Sparta lived on as a fossilized military city, though its military capabilities and more or less stable form of government still were admired by many other Greeks.

The two city-states that best represent each
form of government were Sparta (oligarchy) and Athens (democracy). The democratic government in Athens, though de cently equal, fair and fairly advanced for its time, did not meet the needs of the Greeks. During a time of many military battles Athens decided to worry more about comfort
and culture. It is the oligarchy in Sparta that put a war-like attitude as it's first priority and best met the needs of Ancient Greece.

The Athenian democratic government, which may have given the citizens in Greece more freedom, was not the best form of government at the time. The democracy in Athens cannot really be called a true democracy since there were several flaws in the governme nt and the way it worked. Only ten percent of the total population of Athens actually had voting rights and allof these citizens were upper class men who were over thirty years old. Women, no matter what the class or age, were given no freedom at all.

In the city-state of Sparta, the government was controlled by an oligarchy in which the power was held by a group of five men called ephors. It may not seem very fair that the citizens had little say in the decisions made by the government but, at the time, this was the better government.


For that specific time period the oligarchy government in Sparta was better for the Ancient Greeks than the democratic government in Athens. The government in Athens worried more about the citizens of its city-state
then its own well-being. The Spartan oligarchy may not have given its citizens a lot of freedom but it was successful in gaining attention and respect from the other Greeks and their rival nations.

Answer 3

Which city-state was better is completely debatable depending on criteria: foresight in governmental structure (Athens) or military capability (Sparta). Women surprisingly held a very strong position in the Spartan society while the men held a strong military position. Politically, men held a stronger position in Athens.

Answer 4

Sparta was a better place to live if you were a woman. Unlike their Athenian counterparts, Spartan women were allowed to own property, they were allowed to travel, and were allowed access to the same level of education as men. Spartan women were allowed to take lovers and could negotiate to bring their lover's into the home. It is thought that the concept of adultery was unknown in Sparta and that women were encouraged to have several children with many men to keep the population a healthy size, the Spartan man putting the good of the state ahead of his jealousy over his family.

While well known as a military state, Sparta was equal to or even surpassed Athens in many areas:

Sparta was the first democracy in recorded history, possibly predating Athenian democracy by more than 200 years. (Most historians, however, date it 50 to 100 years before Solon in Athens.)

Sparta was the only Greek city-state to introduce a land reform aimed at equalising wealth among its citizens.

Sparta was the first and only Greek city-state to develop a complex system of mutual defence treaties, and it repeatedly intervened to defend democracy against tyranny.

The Spartan public educational system, the agoge, was admired almost universally by contemporaries, from historians such as Herodotus and Xenophon to philosophers such as Plato and Aristotle.

Although Spartans were proud to say that they built their monuments "in flesh"—meaning that the virtue and courage of Sparta's citizens were the greatest monuments a city-state could possess—they were not lacking in architectural and artistic achievements, as was well catalogued by the Ancient Greek tour-guide, Pausanias.

Spartan music and dance were famous throughout the ancient world, and the oldest recorded heterosexual love poem was the work of a Spartan poet praising Spartan maidens.

Spartan wit and mastery of rhetoric were so widely admired that ancient Greek scholars collected "Spartan sayings" and the "Laconic" style of speech was studied and imitated in intellectual circles.

Answer 5

Sparta and Athens, the two maximum effectual cities of Hellas, did no longer have lots in person-friendly. The Athenians tried to enhance their resourceful and psychological applications, whilst Sparta remained remoted from something of Hellas, with out artwork or literature, with out appropriate homes, with out any progression of their social and political traditions. Sparta lived on as a fossilized militia city, nevertheless its militia applications and greater or much less reliable form of government nevertheless have been well-liked via many different Greeks. the two city-states that superb signify each and each form of government have been Sparta (oligarchy) and Athens (democracy). The democratic government in Athens, nevertheless de cently equivalent, trouble-free and intensely stepped forward for its time, did no longer meet the needs of the Greeks. throughout the time of a time of many militia battles Athens desperate to be afflicted greater approximately convenience and lifestyle. that's the oligarchy in Sparta that placed a conflict-like recommendations-set as that is first priority and superb met the needs of historic Greece. The Athenian democratic government, which will have given the voters in Greece greater freedom, replaced into no longer the superb form of government on the time. The democracy in Athens can't quite be pronounced as a real democracy on the grounds that there have been various flaws in the governme nt and how it worked. purely ten p.c. of the total inhabitants of Athens certainly had balloting rights and allof those voters have been greater type adult males who have been over thirty years previous. women, no count number what the class or age, have been given no freedom in any respect. in the city-state of Sparta, the government replaced into controlled via an oligarchy wherein the skill replaced into held via a team of 5 adult males pronounced as ephors. it might desire to no longer look very trouble-free that the voters had little say in the possibilities made via the government yet, on the time, this replaced into the greater effective government. For that particular term the oligarchy government in Sparta replaced into greater effective for the classic Greeks than the democratic government in Athens. the government in Athens aggravating greater with reference to the voters of its city-state then its very own wellbeing. The Spartan oligarchy would possibly no longer have given its voters extremely some freedom whether it replaced into effectual in gaining interest and appreciate from the different Greeks and their rival international locations.

Answer 6

Athens was the more civilised society as can be seen from the remains of that civilisation. They had better architecture and their philosophers and artists have been renowned over the centuries since then.
Sparta was devoted to warfare and there is little trace of it left

Answer 7

athens was more involved with the arts and had many breakthroughs, sparta was jus very military savvy

Answer 8

Go See 300. Then you will know. The movie is loosely based on an event that happened