Fantasy Baseball Trade???

Question

Tell me who gets the better deal 1 or 2.
1) Brandon Webb
2) Andy Pettite and Nomar

Answer 1

#1, Webb is a dominating starter who scores well in every category and has no history of injuries. Pettitte is already hurt and Nomar is always at risk of being on the DL plus both are older players and that brings health issues even more into play. Chances are Nomar is nothing more than a bench player on most fantasy rosters so it basically is a Pettitte for Webb deal. Plus the guy with Webb would have to cut another player....that means maybe someone along the lines of Nomar in production.

Answer 2

Webb is better than Pettite and should have a better year stats wise although Pettite back with the Yanks should get some wins.
The question is does Nomar as a first baseman up in years, a constant injury threat and not great numbers for a first baseman push up the value enough for Pettite to be equal to Webb.

I would say no. I think you can probably find a good FA first baseman that can equal Nomar's numbers.

Answer 3

webb definatly
he has more ks, and wins and a better era
and nomar sucks so....