More valuable to Indians: Grady Seismore or Travis Hafner?

Question

EAGE
McMDUDE
YAYAYAYAYAYYAYAY

Answer 1

Sizemore. Hafner doesn't have more than two tools. Sizemore has at least two more, and has a higher ceiling. He should take off this year, though probably won't have the slugging numbers that Hafner will have. I still think Grady is more valuable.

Answer 2

i could elect Grady Sizemore cuz Hafner purely have had a undesirable 07' campaign and a nightmare 08' campaigne too. he's finding like a version of Andruw Jones ceremony now. Sizemore is on the threshold of a 5 tooled participant who cancontinual adult men in, score runs, thieve bases and hit homers and to maximum appropriate some that reported he hits for accepted---it is not probably actual..that have continuously been a silence vice of Grady. He would be unable to hit 3 hundred! He strikesout lots! yet unwell nevertheless take him over Hafner.

Answer 3

Travis Hafner cause he's already proved himself more than Grady.

Answer 4

Hafner is more valuable. Sizemore just had a good season and that probably won't happen again.

Answer 5

Sizemore- he is more of an all around offensive threat, plays a good center field, and will be with the Indians for more time in the future.

Answer 6

Grady, because of the position he plays. He will have a break out season this year.

Answer 7

Sizemore is. hafner's a great hitter, but doesn't play the field. sizemore will hit for avg, hit some homers and plays the field.

Answer 8

i think grady. haf is great and is a great hitter but sizemore actually plays a position and has great speed and is a better all around player.

Answer 9

Hafner

You misspelled Sizemore's last name, so I'm answering as if you actually meant Seismore instead of the correct spelling.

Answer 10

Grady he does it with his bat and in the field.