Did anyone watch Supernatural last Thursday?..Why should Sam have to kill the woman he loves...If it had to?

Question

be done, Dean should have done it...I don't think she should have ever asked that of him-it could affect him psychologically for many years...It's really a shame-she was a really nice girl.

Answer 1

i don't think he killed her. i think he let her go and she'll appear in a later episode. sam is not as strong as dean when it comes to killing.

Answer 2

You know, I was thinking about it the other day, and it seemed like the werewolf only came out when she was sleeping, and only during the night. It seems to me that they could have avoided her being a werewolf most of the time if she'd just slept during the day on days of the full moon. Which I find more depressing.
And part of the reason Sam had to do it, because it was kind of this, "look, see, this is what Dean would have to go through" but not really. Sam's going to say, I can do it, why can't you, when it's just not the same thing. Killing a girl you really like and just had sex with is NOT the same as killing the brother you've known your whole life, who you would die for.
So yeah.

Answer 3

Sam had to do it...... if he had let Dean do it, their relationship would have been changed forever. Sam would have always blamed Dean for murdering his girlfriend - regardless of the fact that she was a ill and wanted to die!

Answer 4

I saw the show and I think she wanted him to kill her because she loved him and really trusted him. Also, I think Sam agreed to kill her because he loved her and her last wish was for him to kill her.

I couldn't have done it.

Answer 5

Well someone had to kill her so he could meet me, fall in love with me & I could have his beautiful babies. Believe me, it is best that she dies. I will help him through his pain, I promise. ;)