Should I Do Vladmir Guerrero for Roy Halladay or Roy Oswalt?

Question

My starting pitching right now is Lackey, Rich Hill, Ian Snell, Matt Cain, and John Maine

Answer 1

Id say Oswalt considering he will strikeout more then Roy Holladay(said he wants to pitch to contact more) Not to Mention of all pitchers qualifing for the ERA title last year in both leagues he was one of only two pitchers with an era under 3.00. There offense is improved from last year and with his pitching his stats will be very very impressive this year and he will compete for the Cy Young.

Answer 2

Find someone else to trade besides Vlad he gives you too much where Oswalt and Halladay are injury proned if you're looking for a pitcher try someone who hasn't missed a start in a while such as Zito or Zambrano.

Answer 3

id go with neither. you can get more than that from vlad. both roys are 3rd round picks at best, while vlad is a late first early 2nd. so i would trade for oswalt and ask the guy for more.

Answer 4

This is a one sided trade against you. Maybe if you include Snell, and get both. Do not trade Vlad even up for one of those guys.

Answer 5

i would go with roy oswalt because halladay is toying with his pitches saying he wants to prolong his career by not throwing as much heat so he wants more contact for outs rather than k's so go with oswalt who throws heat

Answer 6

both are really good but i would say Oswalt, I have Halladay on my team, but Toranto isn't that good compared to the Astros

Answer 7

you have a weak pitching staff. i'd go w/halladay (b/c i have him on my team).

Answer 8

that is stupid Vlad is one of the best

Answer 9

i say don't trade Vladimir he is too good he is too kekin