Should the Dolphins go for T. Grenn, D. Carr, a rookie or giving a Culppeper another chance?

Question

I go for Culppeper another chance...

Answer 1

Trent Green is getting too old, Daunte Culpeppers is injury prone and cannot play at all if he's not 100%, so the obvious answer would be David Carr. Carr has a lot of potential, young, and just needs an offensive line that can protect him. He has been leading the league in sacked QB and that is because he doesn't get any help. Put some players behind him and he should develop into an excellent quarterback. Hallelujah hollaback.

Answer 2

Well I would think that Trent Green has the Better advantage of the three Qbs well because he seems to be the one whose lasted longer without injury and has gone further with his team(s) that hes played for. Because Dante Culpepper seems to be getting hurt just about ever year and Well David Carr hes kinda the Young one of the 3 and hes been playing for a team that really isn't the best on the NFL and Plus he was CUT by that team anyways so if you can't even be good enough to play for a team that pretty much(in my mind/eyes) Sucks in the NFL you Have to be pretty bad so why would the Dolphins want you(Dvaid Carr). So back to what I said in the Beginning I think that Trent Green has the best chance to be the Better on of the QBs of those three QBs and I think that the Miami Dolphins shoule get him.

Answer 3

Being from Missouri and making me a Chiefs and Rams fan I've had the opportunity to see Green play. Now 3 or more years ago I would say go for Green, he was a awesome QB who kinda like Warner in his prime had that real cool level headed mentality under stress in the pocket and had a very accurate throwing arm. But now a few years older and a couple hundred hits latter, he's not the same QB he once was. Also the same could be said for Culppeper though I think he might have at least another 2 good seasons under his belt, he's had a good run and made enough money to live the rest of his life comtorably. I say time to step down and let some new blood take over.

Answer 4

none of the above. Green is washed up and nothing more. He is past his prime and why waste a draft pick!
Culpepper was a product of the system and Randy Moss. As soon as he lost Moss he sucked in Minnesota and he'll suck in Miami. His greatest asset was his mobility which he no longer has which will make him a career backup unless someone is desperate!
David Carr is probably your best option! Everyone here can say he stinks but have you ever had 250-300 pound men tearing your head off while you try to throw to below average recievers behind the second worst line in football?
I think you trade culpepper for a 4th round pick, give up on green, sign carr and let him and lemon battle for the job.
For the guy who said that you have ricky williams back, if they let him come back it shows you why the dolphins suck the best quarterback on your team is a wide reciever give him a chance and i think you'd be suprised.(Marcus Vick)

Answer 5

I think they should trade Culppeper to the Raiders to reunite him with Randy Moss this should jump start both their careers. But then again Im a Raiders fan... so in the best interest of the Dolphins they should get Trent Grenn and challenge the two, and throw in Cleo Lemon in the mix. I think Lemon has a shot since he worked with Coach Cameron in San Diego. Honestly I think they should have stuck with Joey Harrington he was getting better but Nick Saban had to go and ruin his confidence by benching him. I mean he lead them to shut out the Bears!!! Either way they need some help at wide out. I mean right now Hagan and Marcus Vick are battling for the 3rd wide receiver position... and Chambers man I have no idea what happened to him last year... maybe he just needs a qb with an arm that can throw deep to him. But remember they have ronnie brown and ricky williams will be coming back... and with porter their defense will be even better.

Answer 6

Really sounds like you are going to end up with Trent Green and if that happens then Culpepper is history. If the Trent Green deals falls through then I see the Dolphins going after Carr. Either way it seems obvious that Culpepper is the out man in Miami and rightly so. His talents were marginal when he was at his prime, his injuries have taken away the best attribute he had, his mobility.

Answer 7

I keep Culpepper because he's all ready proven he can play at a high level and sign Carr just in case Dante doesn't recover from that injury.......

Trent Green is a very good quarterback but has maybe 1 or 2 years left, I believe he's 37yrs old and you would be putting everything into winning this year......

Carr can be just as effective and is 27yrs old so it gives your franchise several years of possible playoff teams and possible championships.

Answer 8

I say Culpepper if he is healthy. Obviously Cam Cameron either doubts Daunte is or his ablities since they are pursuing veteren QB's. Otherwise I'd go with David Carr and draft a young QB. I like Trent Green but his age and that concussion last year really scares me. He'd be a better fit, especially if the Fins get Brady Quinn somehow.

Answer 9

You are kidding right? Although I never would have taken Culpepper in the first place. I would go for Green. If I didn't like his price I would look at Carr, and would likely already be talking to his agent to see what the deal would be.

Answer 10

I'd go for T Green 1st...if the cost is to high I'd sign Carr as a back-up and pray Culpepper is healthy.

Y'all have only 2 QB's on roster...Culpepper and Lemon...definetly need someone else.