Fantasy Baseball Trade?

Question

Who gets the better deal?

Chase Utley and Brett Myers

4

Travis Hafner, C.C. Sabathia, and Matt Cain

Answer 1

Whoever gets the Hafner/Sabathia/Cain part of the deal. No question Utley is a dominant 2nd sacker and by far the best fantasy 2nd sacker but Kronk has a monster bat also and the 2 pitchers for 1 sways the deal for the 2nd guy. Cain looks every bit like a dominating pitcher and Sabathia is a proven quality starter. Myers is also proven and very good but the advantage goes to the guy getting the hafner package. All that being said you would need to see how they fit for each guy and what it does to the roster (without seeing both rosters we can only speculate on the players offered) and who would the guy have to cut that gets 3 players for 2 (obviously someone has to go...would it be a quality guy?). If you already have a big bat that could be your DH then dealing for Hafner wouldnt be much help and who would replace Utley? These are important factors that make the deal good or not for each guy.

Answer 2

Id take the 2 over the 3. Utley is king of 2b this year and Myers is some consolation for loss of CC and MC.

Answer 3

well it would depend on your league and how it is run but chase and Brett are a better two then hafner cc and Matt
Travis is good but it depends on how many utility positions you get if it is just one then that locks up one spot and then you cant make changes cc is just not very good any he is only and OK pitcher and Matt is horrible he is still to unproven to have to be relied on/'/

Answer 4

Any time you got the MAN at a spot, you are ahead in the game. Most leagues I play have constant turnover of pitching, and there will be pitchers that rise up from obscurity to catch your eye. Just figure out that you will also need to drop a player, so for the sake of figuring, pretend that player is part of the trade and see how it looks then.

Answer 5

depends on your league

Answer 6

Do iT!!!