Greatest QB then and now????

Question

Who do you think was or is the greatest QB then and now?

Answer 1

Then:

Joe Montana - absolutely incredible with the Jerry Rice tandem in San Fran.

Johnny Unitas - doesn't get enough love because he's so much older, but was THE premiere QB before the flash days of Namath. The guy played with a horribly injured shoulder and at one point a broken arm. And still managed to win league championships.

Now:

Peyton Manning - I know a lot of people say Brady because of the championships, but it's not about the championships. He's consistantly a QB that throws with a passer rating in the high 90's, low 100's. In 2004 he had the highest passer rating ever, surpassing Steve Young and Joe Montana with 121.1. He's already blown a few QB/Receiving records out of the water with Marvin Harrison and set the single season touchdown record in 2004. And now that he's won the Super Bowl, the whole "he can't win the big one" should be over.

And what people tend to forget, is of current QB's, he owns more passing/touchdown records in then any QB currently in the league (around 6 total). That's including Tom Brady and Brett Favre.

Answer 2

Then Marino, no question. Come on Joe Montana had so much talent with him it isn't even close. Do you think Montana could have done what he did without the running game and line he had not to mention the defense and receivers? Marino had a good line and receivers. No running game and a decent defense, but yet the made the playoffs over and over. Just because you don't win the superbowl doesn't mean you not the best at the position. All I have to say is Berry Sanders is the best running back of all time, not Roger Craig right? The best now is Manning, he is setting records and plays every game. He is not only good, but very tough.

Answer 3

Then: Otto Graham or Bart Starr. Both were winners in their careers. Graham never played on a losing team, and won 6 championships(10 including AAFC). Bart Starr lost only one postseason game as a starter, and was the MVP of the first 2 Super Bowls in an era where passing was not big. He also made great decisions. He had a streak of 294 straight pass attempt without an interception.

Now: That is always open for debate. It's just like the Elway/Marino question before Elway won a Super Bowl. If I was to pick one, it would be Payton Manning. He has great recivers, but should that be held against him? Bradshaw had great recievers, but he is not thought of as a bad QB. Manning has size, strength, quick release, and accuracy. Given time, he will win another Super Bowl.

Answer 4

properly, i think of you would be directly to something. indexed right here are my concepts in this. once you look into history, all the super QB's had super WR's. you have Peyton Manning and Marvin Harrison, Joe Montana & Jerry Rice, and such as you point out at one element you had Moss and Culpepper. even with the undeniable fact that one concern that all and sundry of those pairs had in straightforward became skills. because it pertains to a QB, i think that the 1st element is skills. think of roughly it this form, a QB would properly be good, yet while the WR that they could artwork with, drops balls, fumbles, and might't catch, then what does the QB could artwork with? i'm no longer refuting your element that Brady has accomplished properly with little to artwork with by way of fact your splendid. even with the undeniable fact that if a QB has an typical or undesirable WR then the stats will teach. case in point, if a QB has a terrible WR, and he continously throws to that WR and he keeps dropping balls or fails to catch, then what occurs is that his stats go through. My element is that WR's are there to compliment and advance the stats of a QB. If the QB has a brilliant extensive reciever that would catch and get better yardage then his stats bypass up, in any different case they bypass down. Its all related to the mixed skills.. in spite of the reality that i could say that a QB may additionally make performs ensue and we've seen that with the likes of Donovan McNabb and Michael Vick..

Answer 5

I will say for now it is Tom Brady.I am a Patriots fan so I am biased but if I have to win one game,I want Brady to be QB.Sorry Peyton!!Joe Montana for the past QB

Answer 6

Joe Montana
tom Brady

Answer 7

Then-Joe Montana(ever)

Now-Tom Brady

Answer 8

Bart Starr
Payten Manning

Answer 9

Then: John Elway

Now: Peyton Manning

Answer 10

Then- Joe Montana, and John Elway.
Now- Carson Palmer and Peyton Manning