Should I trade Francisco Rodriguez for Michael Young?

Question

My only SS is Khalil Greene. My RP's are Joe Nathan, BJ Ryan, and Tom Gordon. The other manager is also interested in Roy Oswalt. My other SP's are Chris Carpenter, Roy Halladay, Ian Snell, Chris Capuano, and Jeff Francis.

Answer 1

Young is a quality SS but Rodriguez is possibly the most dominant closer in the game. It isnt a good deal for you....if Greene can stay healthy (big if, I know) he will post numbers very close to Youngs with the exception of BA. Maybe offer up gordon for someone like Lugo, if nothing else he will score over 100 runs hitting at the top of the Red Sox lineup. See if he would take Halladay for Young, Oswalt isnt as big an injury risk and if you deal him and Halladay has more arm problems your solid pitching staff suddenly looks very weak. If he wont do that deal then i would hold tight and see if Greene can stay healthy....he is killing the ball this spring and you end up with a bargain SS and dominating pitching.

Answer 2

w/ K-Rod you can get better than Michael Young. Try for Tejada or Jeter. More than likely you'll drop Khalil Greene after the SS pickup however.

Answer 3

No, keep K-Rod and trade him for a better SS. K-Rod is the best RP in the game. I got Jeter for Wagner try something like that. If not tell him tradin BJ for Young is more fair.

Answer 4

You are VERY deep at closers, but you still would be overpaying with a guy like K-Rod. I would offer Tom Gordon for Young since he's your 4th closer. Closer's are very coveted after the first few weeks so make sure you get good value for him.

Answer 5

You needless to say win interior the Sizemore deal and your going to wish a warm hitter like Bruce as Soriano and Pujols are injured. Plus Lee shouldn't maintain it up. i might extremely have Beckett interior the long-term than Lee.