rate my team, 2007 fantasy football keeper leauge?

Question

RB: Shawn Alexander, rudi johnson, brandon jacobs,
WR: marvin harrison, steve smith, darrel jackson, deion branch, keyshawn johnson,
QB: Donovan, steve mcnair, alex smith
TE: Vernon davis, ben watson
K: vinatieri, neil rackers, david akers
def: chargers, bengals, eagles

we get to have a big bench in this league, lots of backups.
only starting 1 quarterback, 2 or 3 runningbacks(depending if u play 2 or 3 WR), 2 or 3 WR (depending if u play 2 or 3 runningbacks), 1 tightend, 1 kicker, 1 def


rate 1-10, ten being best, please comment as well

Answer 1

9 out of 10. Shawn Alexander & Rudi Johnson are going to give up numbers because he's exceptional. Marvin Harrison is Peyton's favorite target and should continue increase his stats. Steve Smith is the offense of the Panthers, he's definitely racking up yards as usual. Donovan, McNair, and Smith aren't A-list quarterbacks but are efficient. Neil Rackers should rack up his points from last season. The defenses are great but don't cause to much turnovers except the Cincinnati Bengals.

Answer 2

I'd say about a 6 or 7. OK I'm guessing that Shaun Alexander will have a decent season with this. As to WRs just not sure about that. Yeah Harrison will get you good usually, and I think you could get 3 out of it pretty good. QB is probably one that I really worry about. Ok even if you think McNabb is great(sorry I don't) you almost expect him to get hurt. You are looking at McNair who is aged body-wise. I am just not sold enough on Alex Smith is my big problem there. I think you should do decent, although would almost have to see the other teams to really compare.

Answer 3

I would say a five.

You have big name RB's, but Alexander looked very human without his dominant line from his MVP year. And it isn't getting any better in Seattle.

Rudi doesn't impress me. He'll have 165 in a game and then not crack 50 yards the next three games. Too inconsistent.

Jacobs looked like he was going to be primed for a nice year, but the Giants picked up Droughns. I guess they figured that a big back like Jacobs can't play a lot of downs.

I would try to trade one of your backs.

Your WR's are decent. I don't like having receivers from the same team though, so I would try to move D Jack, since he seems to miss 5-6 games a year.

McNabb will be okay. I like the Eagles with Curtis. He's a nice option for McNabb. I actually think that Alex Smith is going to play well this year too. Keep him tucked away, you'll probably have some other teams offering to trade for him by the mid-point of the season.

The rest of the team seems about average except for Vinateri.

Good luck.

Answer 4

I give your team a 7 1/2 lots of points with those backs and recievers but you are weak at QB and Defense I think chargersOffense will be adjusting to a new system which is going to keep their D out there more than they would like, this will be their downfall this year tight ends dont get you many points but those are two great ones davis is going to have a breakout year I think and watson will be wide open for the screen now that the pats have some recievers I would start him.

Answer 5

The quarterbacks aren't awful but McNabb might get hurt again and McNair lacked the offensive leadership to win late last year. Hang on to Alex Smith and see if you can snag Garcia, Brady, or Palmer through a trade. One other question - why three kickers? (8/10)

Answer 6

eh 6-7 id take peterson(whe he comes out) over shawn alexander
haha u should pick up JP Losman- i think he had a better qb rating then all of your qb's and he can make huge passes, and my guess would be that he's relatively cheap
pstriots D should be smokin this year
wr's pretty good, dont forget about Lee Evans, he had 3 touchdowns for more than 80 yrds each inone game
kicker- vinatieri cant go wrong,
the rest looks well-

Answer 7

9 for this up coming year... but i would really try and trade some of your older players for younger ones why they still have some value. If you can try and get colston from the saints. Hes young and should have a nasty career. -> Even a Harrison for Colston trade would be worth it. Harrison is old and Colston was leading the NFL last year before he got injured.

Pick up Brandon Marshall from the Bronocos. He was a rookie last year but showd a lot of promise and with rod smith getting REALLY old he shold be a starter by the end of the season at the lastest.

Answer 8

Actually, 8.5 I think people and underrating Donovan. He has a chip on his shoulder and wants to prove he belongs in the elite. As long as you don't have to play your other QBs you look good.

Your TE is mediocre at best. Frank Gore will be getting most of the attention in SF. I think we are going to see Alex Smith dumping off to him more than Davis.

I think your defenses are your weak points. The Chargers will be as good as Merriman is and the Bengalsperformance depends on any parole restrictions.

Answer 9

8, not a bad team at all. try to get better qbs (mcnabb is out for most of next year) and you have a good bunch of WR

Answer 10

8 but your tight end position is not all that good