PLZ rate my fantasy baseball team 1-100, (100=fantastic, 1=terrible) and also i got this brain buster trade.?

Question

Some information first. Im in a 5x5 league, head to head, 10 team league.

This is my team

c-paul lo duca nym

1b-conor jackson ari

2b- dan uggla fla

3b- garrett atkins col

ss- jose reyes nym

of- grady sizemore cle

of- jason bay pit

of- juan pierre lad

util- raul lbanez sea

bench

freddy sanchez pit

alex gordon kc

sp- carlos zambrano chc

sp- scott kazmir tb

rp- mariano rivera nyy

rp- francisco cordero mil

p- john smoltz

p- jered weaver

bench

jonathan papelbon bos

cole hamels phi

brain fuetes col

So what do u think of my team?

I GOT THIS TRADE AND I CANT DESIDE IF TO ACCEPT OR DECLINE

IM GETTING MATT HOLIDAY I GIVE JASON BAY

shoud i accept the trade?

one owner in my league is trying to trade r.howard should i go for howard and iff yes who do i trade in return?

Answer 1

C- as a mets fan, i like lo duca, but he will not be a big fantasy producer, i would try to packasge him and another player for a better catcher

1B- Conor Jackson is a solid first baseman, arizona could be great this year if there pitching is good and jackson should hit 20-25 homers and maybe 100 rbis

2b- i dont know about uggla, he couldve been a one year wonder, but he still should be able to produce solid numbers

3b- aatkins will hit well since hes playing in colorado, so hes a great 3b to have

SS- BEST SHORTSTOP EVER!

OF- sizemore is great, but i dont' like bay. ibanez could have a great year but its very questionable. i think hes a good #3 utility. Juan Pierre will steal some bases but not alot else, i would trade him and lo duca for a catcher (b/c your bench is very strong)

Bench- Sanchez is very streaky, but hes good to have b/c of the triple position eligibility. I love gordon, hes a possible rookie of year and he hits for power , has some spped and should get on alot.

pitchers- both of your starters are good, as long as kazmir comes back okay from his injury (he should get about 10-12 wins and a 4.00 era) zambrano is excellent. Smoltz is obviously good and weaver should do well again.

Relievers- excellent

Bench- i would actually play hamels instead of weaver, b/c
he seems like more of an upside to me, hes going to strike out a ton opf hitters, Papelbon has looked fantastic in the spring so far, hes good to have, in case kazmir hurts himself, i dont kno much about fuentes

Grade- 89, great team your outfield is fairly weak, but your pitvhing makes up for it.

I would do the trade b/c i dontlike bay and holliday is in a hitter's park.

Answer 2

78...C and 1B is a little weak but other than that you have a solid overall offense. Zambrano is a lights out pitcher and will get more wins with the Cubs this year. Same for Kazmir because he is an amazing young talent. Rivera and Cordero are solid closers that will get you at least 30 saves, 60 K's...Smoltz and Weaver had great years last year and Weaver should be even better playing a full year. Your bench for pitching is really good. I would consider starting Hamels over Smoltz or Fuentes over Cordero. Secondly, I would do that trade because Holliday can get any stats and is on a better team and has a better average. Lastly, I wouldnt go for Howard because that manager is going to want a lot for him and that will just disrupt the balance of your team.

Answer 3

Don't accept trade. Holiday isn't a sure thing. Bay is much more solid and with LaRoche, he should have alittle protection. The nice order of Sanchez, Bay, LaRoche is much better now than anything the Rockies can put up because Helton is aging and on the downside.

As far as your team, I would give you an 80. You are weak at 1B. I would consider trading one of your SS for a front line 1B if you can. Maybe you can package Sanchez and one of your bench RP for someone like Delgado. His avg wouldn't be great but his RBI and power would definately be a BIG help.

Answer 4

I woud give your team an 85-88 out of 100. You have a great balance of speed, average, and power in your starting lineup with a lot of underrated players that will put up consistent numbers. A little more power would be good but you should fair well. HR is ony one category. Yes, do the trade. Holliday is going to be a beast this year. Don;t pursure Howard, he will cost you too much.

Answer 5

As the expert that I am......Your team seems to lack power hitting, but pitching is a strongpoint. You should lead the league in steals and K's. DO NOT accept the trade, I'm not sold on Holliday and Bay may have an even bigger year (he is also your only Power Hitter).

90/100 -- Only because of power
Decline trade

Answer 6

i like your team a lot. you have a nice balance of players and great pitchers i would give you a 75-85 rank. I don't like doing trades before the season starts...i would wait if you can and see how they do...but if you have to decide now then i would see how they are roding in spring training...any medical problems and so on...also i would figure out why that person is trading Holiday....other then that i like your pitching and OF (dont know why you would mess with it)

Answer 7

good pitching but you need some pop and I would do the trade.

Answer 8

80
i don't know how many teams are in your league.

Answer 9

01....thanks for asking ...good luck in your league