Have an opinion about the fields of psychology or psychiatry that you wouldn't mind sharing?

Question

I am particularly interested if anyone agrees or disagrees that the fields are not meant to help people but keep them sick and, thus, lifelong consumers of the industry.

And if you want to say anything, so long as it's related to the psychology or psychiatry industries, claim your two points!

I guess I should have clarified. I'm referring to psychology and psychiatry - in practice - as opposed to the theory studied in college. I'm talking about the practice or act of engaging in therapies like 'talk' therapy or cognitive-behavioral therapy. I'm talking about prescribing patients with psychotropic medications.

I didn't dislike the answer about school. It's just not what I was trying to get at. I agree that studying psychology is very useful no matter the profession one intends to enter. It's also very interesting. It's also mostly theory (at least at the undergraduate level as that's where I studied the subject).

Sadly, I just think something has gone wrong with it all. Or maybe there's something wrong with me that cannot be fixed. I'm open to the possibility. I just can't understand why I've been trying to get help for some time and nothing is working. It's actually been causing more problems and not fixing any.

Answer 1

The fields themselves, at the root, are not meant to keep people sick. However, anytime you insert humans into the equation, the end result will have something to do with profit and power. Take psychiatry. The basis is pure. Take people who have legitimate biological issues mixed with psychological issues, treat them with a mix of medicine and therapy, and help them get better. That sounds great in theory. Let's use depression for example. In an effort to over-simplify the issue for argument's sake, there are two basic causes for depression: chemical (biological), and psychological. I'll further explain. Someone has a reduced amount of seratonin in their brain...that's chemical. Someone's wife/husband of 40 years leaves them...that is psychological. Now, both can theoretically treated with medicine, but why treat something that's not a chemical imbalance with chemicals? Because it's a quick fix and it's profitable.

You see, it's not only the industry who makes it the way you indicate. The consumers are just as much to blame overall. There are the people like you who are searching for a real answer, but unfortunately, the majority just want a quick fix instead of taking a little bit of persnal responsibility...they just want to feel good now with no effort on their part. So, the industry says here, take this and everything will be ok...you'll always be happy. The problem is, once those chemicals have been introduced to your brain for any extended period of time, your body becomes dependent on them. It says, you're giving me these chemicals, so I don't have to produce them. So, if you ever do stop taking the meds, the problem is even worse than it was before. This is also why when you diagnose a kid with ADD or ADHD when he/she really doesn't have it, then give them a Rx for Adoral, the turn into a zombie b/c the chemicals in their brain were fine, and you just screwed them all up.

Now, as for non-medicinal treatment, that's simple. Some people in positions of power want to control other people. Think about it, how easy would it be as a psychologist to control your clients? Sadly, there are those out there who really think that way. Maybe not every client, but some. It's a big tangled web.

But, over all, I still maintain that psychology and psychiatry are jsut like all other medicnal industries... the base intent is to help people. But, people will always find a way to turn good intent into profit, and the people out there who really want to help someone become the minority.

As for the answers you are looking for, there are a multitude of possibilities. Maybe you haven't found anyone yet who really cares about helping people and who would work to find the root of the problem. Also, maybe it's something new, some uncharted territiory. Maybe it's some twist to something that's already known about. Humans actually have the audacity to believe we understand our own minds and the power they possess, when really we aren't even close. Don't give up on the industry, though. There are people out there who want to help you. Unfortunately, it is up to you to find them.

Good luck

Answer 2

It relies upon what you prefer to do extremely. Psychiatry helps those with their issues by counselling classes/drugs. Psychology is reading how the concepts works based on the behaviour of persons (as detrimental to neurology it incredibly is reading the concepts from a chemical perspective). So, very many times: psychology is doing analyze (many times in an educational ecosystem). Psychiatry is working with people to cause them to greater advantageous (like a physician - and for this reason greater advantageous paid too). I did psychology for some years at college and punctiliously enjoyed it. Get a pair of books by ability of Oliver Sacks ("the guy Who Mistook His spouse For A Hat" is a private typical) and notice in case you detect it thrilling! desire that helps!

Answer 3

No, they are not intentionally meant to keep people sick. It may seem that way, for reasons of which we are not aware. Patients often resist treatment or simply don't follow therapists' advice. It may be difficult for a given therapist to accurately diagnose the problem and determine a relevant treatment.

And, of course, every field has its unscrupulous practitioners.

Answer 4

I disagree, first of all, let's say GENERAL PSYCHOLOGY - it teaches us about empirical and conceptual foundations of psychology in its main fields. It also teaches PERCEPTION and PERSONALITY (systematic approaches to the understanding of personality functions and dynamics), ABNORMAL PSYCHOLOGY (introduction to psychoanalysis, behaviorism, humanism, and transpersonal psychology in both theory and therapy)

BA/BS Psychology - provides the student exposure to the wide range of psychological theories and research methodologies which can be useful preparation for further professional training as psychologists, medical doctors, lawyers or for work in schools, industry, media, and other social agencies in various capacities involving research, counseling, psychological testing, personnel work, training and planning.