Peyton....Or Brady?

Question

Peyton Manning and the Colts finally won a superbowl!!! now, that Manning has one under the belt,who is the better QB, Manning (1 ring in the past year), or Brady (3 rings in 4 years), Also, Who has more left in the tank? Answer both for best answer points.

Answer 1

brady got lucky with his wins? are you stupid? were not talking 1 super bowl were talking 3 in 4 years. thats not luck. manning with his 1 in poorly played turnover game is luck. how mnay games has brady won in the past to get to his superbowls? thank you i rest my case. don't be jealous. brady is a far better qb then payton and payton is pretty good

Answer 2

Tom no question. first of all he is the come back king and Peyton's come back in the AFC champ was luck. also if you have to cheat your way into a Superbowl ( #41) then you nor your team are very good. also for those who say the colts will repeat i don't see where that's coming from there major contributors are gone. the pats on the other hand could of and should of had another Superbowl win this year and with out bull penalties would have beat the the colts have just been improving. so they will win Superbowl 42 in Glendale Arizona. Bottom line Tom Brady wins!! And tom will be playing (well mind you) long after manning. i see another run like Farve except without all the overatedness.

Answer 3

This one never gets old. Anyway, the answer is Manning. Both QB's are good, but Manning does a lot more than Brady. Comparing talent, I can't do that from a TV screen. But I know this much, in order to beat the patriots, you dont worry about stopping Tom Brady as much as you worry about stopping Manning. A lot of Brady's yard came off of play fakes to the running back, or short screens which turned into large gains. Manning on the other hand is the focal point to the entire Colts offensive. He's the field general, running the offense, calling audilbles, doing it all. Because of his ability to read defenses, and call the best play, and the weight on his shoulders, I'd say he's better. Its so much easier to play a game when the expectations aren't as high, and when you dont have to do it all. When you can hand it off and let your defense win it for you, as Brady did in all his superbowls. I have never seen brady lead his team back from a deficiet in the playoffs, when everything is on the line. When Brady was forced to abandon the run and screens, what happened to his team, they lost.

I would assume the younger athlete would have more in the tank, but I'm not so sure. I think Manning still has a lot more to proove. Being as good as he is, it isn't enough that he win one super bowl ring, or if he gets five more. Manning is on such a higher pedestal, that he not only has to get more rings, he has to stay getting so many touchdowns, and not get any interceptions. Brady got three rings already, and lets not forget, he was a 6-7 rounder. He accomplished a lot more than anyone thought he would. If he does nothing else, people would still say Brady is good. Manning still has to do a lot more, so I think knowing that, his drive would be greater than Brady's.

Answer 4

Brady is. He won after being a no name back up QB for the Patriots in his 2nd year. Then he did go on and won two more. Yes his defense was a big part of those wins, but defense can't win a game alone.

Peyton Manning is good. As long as he doesn't get hit. Dallas Cowboys managed to beat the vaunted Colts by getting to him. He's good, but Brady is better under pressure and therefore is the better QB.

As to who has more left in the tank, I'm not certain. Baring injuries I think they will both retire around the same time. Probably Peyton first since he has been playing longer.

Answer 5

Tom Brady. He is a very talented QB. Compare Peyton's recivers to Brady's. Brady had to work with guys picked up off the street basically, Reche Caldwell and Jabar Gaffney. With those two recivers, he still took his team to the AFC Championship game. Brady makes his recivers GREAT. Peyton's recivers make him look great. Tom Brady has more rings with many more coming up with a new, fresh and GREAT receiving corps led by Donte Stallworth, Kelly Washington, and Wes Welker. Brady has a much better playoff record than Peyton even though Manning has been in the league longer. Brady is 13-3 in the post season. Brady has 24 career 4th Q. combacks, and Brady is very effective and consistant.

Tom Brady has more left in his tank because he is younger and has a better offensive line. Tom will win atleast 2 more Super Bowls. His PRIME is just about to begin.

Answer 6

To the first I would have to say it is Manning, but only because he has more weapons to work with. Think about it, Tom Brady led the Pats to another AFC Championship game with receivers like Reche Cladwell and Ben Watson. Manning unlike Brady has never had to deal with the shifting of receivers like Brady has. Now I'm not saying Manning isn't good. He had another record year and that is why I think he is better right now. But if you stuck Brady on the Colts and Manning on the Pats of last year then I would say Brady is better. As for the upcoming football season, I think that Brady with a much improved wide receiver corp will be better then Manning.
As for your second question, I don't think it really matters. In essence think about it, they are both pocket QBs and don't run a lot, the only hits they get are from being rushed or sacked. Although Brady is the younger of the two by about a year, they both experience the same amount of hits. I guess it just depends on who keeps winning because I don't care what anybody says, if your winning you want to keep playing.

Answer 7

This has to be the most asked question on Yahoo Answers, but it never gets old. Manning has more talent, that goes without saying. There is no match for him right now, and by the end of his career, he might even be the best ever, we'll see. Brady....he's a winner. He's not the best QB in the world like Dan Marino, Brett Favre, or Troy Aikman, but Brady just goes out there and leads his team to wins. I'd say Manning's a better player, but Brady's a better team leader.

More left in the tank? They both have how many consecutive starts? I think they'll both last quite a while, although maybe not Favre-like time, but certainly they can go on for a while. I might be inclined to say Manning though because of his offensive line...the guy just never takes big hits and therefore should be able to play at high levels for longer.

Answer 8

Peyton Manning may have better career stats then Tom Brady but Tom Brady has won more then Peyton Manning has. In my opinion I think that Tom Brady has more left in the tank then Peyton Manning simply becuase he's a couple of years younger then Peyton Manning.

Answer 9

SO WHAT BRADY CAME OFF THE BENCH! PEYTON MANNING DID IT TOO. If you take a look back at history, you modernized new skooled analysts, Peyton Manning sat behind TWO quatrerbacks at the beginning of his college career. And you know who was ahead of him? Todd Helton, a baseball player. And the next person in line was a quarterback nobody' ever heard of.Brady started at Michigan. Peyton Manning has the stats to prove Brady wrong, the height, and the arm. Brady's had the better team since he came into the NFL. Colts have better talent, but the Patriots were A TEAM. BUT, Peyton Manning is better, watch both the regular seasoon Colts -pats game, and the AFC chanmpionship game.

Answer 10

Tom Brady is still the better quarterback. He still has more superbowl rings. Peyton Manning has plenty of talent in his recieving core which make his job a whole lot easier. While Tom Brady has younger, less experienced recievers and still had a great season. My conclusion is that Tom Brady is a better quarterback because he did more with less.

Answer 11

Brady .......he got all 3 without a star receiver and will be back for #4 this year.

Manning is a good QB but the bears handed him the Superbowl.