Trade for Albert Pujols?

Question

Should I trade Manny Ramirez, Jimmy Rollins and B.J. Ryan for Albert Pujols, Freddy Sanchez and Billy Wagner?

Answer 1

Lets compare this one for a minute
Manny Ramirez vs. Pujols
Pujols wins hands down
Jimmy Rollins vs Freddy Sanchez
Equal
B.J Ryan vs. Billy Wagner
Billy Wagner wins(he's proven it year in and year out)
I say its a good trade

ok for more on the The Jimmy Rollins// Freddy Sanchez comparsion for people who dont believe its even look at this two stats:
Sanchez ab 582-runs 85-hits 200-rbi 85 k-52-sb 3-obp .378
Rollins ab 689-runs 127-hits 191-rbi 83 k-80-sb36-obp.334
So Rollins had 100 more abouts less hits more strikeouts by far a lower batting avg and a lot lower on-base-percentage
Runs this year will be equal because both team have good run producers behind them phillies have howard/utley and pirates have Laroche/bay..
Sanchez had less at bats, less homers and less steals
and will get better this year
In comparsion they both contribute very well as i said they are equal

Answer 2

YES!!! Manny is dropping, while Pujols is always on the rise. I think Sanchez is equal to Rollins, and Ryan is barely better than Wagner.

Answer 3

YES DO IT, Pujols is the best fantasy baseball player. Manny isn't a great player because he gets hurt a lot. Also Sanchez good have another great year as the Batting Champ. yes Rollins is better than Sanchez and Wanger is As good as Ryan. BUT YOU ARE GETTING PUJOLS SO DO IT.

Answer 4

If your getting Pujols, yes.

Ryan and Wagner pretty much are equals although Wagner has proven his ability for a longer time.

Rollins is considerably better than Sanchez.

However, Pujols is the best fantasy player in the game and any time you get a chance to pick him up you have to take the chance.

Answer 5

um are you kidding? hell yes. dude hes albert pujols.

and the guy that said rollins and freddy are even doesnt know wut the heck ehs talking about.

Albert vs. Manny
their stat output is actually not so far off. pujols will get a little higher AVG. but the main concern is taht manny wont play either due to injury (he is 34) or he just doesnt feel like playing.

Rollins vs. Freddy
No competition its rollins. rollins is a stud. freddy sucks. he gives you help in 1 stat. AVG. rollins got a new coach who says he will steal 40 bags this year. and hes got the speed. so rollins could go .280 score 120 drive in 80 not to mention with 20HRs and 40steals to boot. tahts 2nd round status.

BJ vs Wagner
BJ is better. why? well lets see. 35 fastball throwers arent great options. why? cuz theyre arms wear out. BJ will out perform billy for sure but not by that much. If it was me I would prefer manny, rollins, and BJ just cuz rollins is SO much better than freddy. but he is albert. so i thik it really comes down to your roster. if you have a good OF in waiting then go for it, but if you already got a 1B then no. i really dont like it

Answer 6

Wagner and Ryan are pretty even. Then I'd rather have Pujols and Sanchez than ManRam and JRol. I'd say go for it.

Answer 7

I would say no, only for this reason:

If you project Pujols' number if he DIDNT spend time on the DL, he would have hit 57 HR.

A player that is fully capapble of .335-60-140-10 is not a guy you trade, under any circumstances.

Answer 8

i would keep manyy and crew....manny could match Pujols in HR and avg, Rollins could hit 25 hr, 40 sbs, 130 runs...Ryan is better than wagner - don't do it unless you can trade someone like Chris Ray instead of Ryan.

Answer 9

Yes!!! Pujols is outstanding. . .the leader!!! Sanchez is well on his way and Wagner is a sure thing.

Answer 10

u would definetley not be giving up enough for pujols because just think pujols is the best playa in the league right know