Does anyone know how much a 1935 and a 1923 buffulo nickel is worth?

Answer 1

OK, follow these 1,2,3 easy steps :

1) Grade your Buffalo Nickel with image and description aid :
http://www.geocities.com/RodeoDrive/4044/grade.html

2) Check the mint :
Mint marks are underneath the words "Five Cents".
Either a D(Denver) or S(San Francisco); else if no alphabets means Philadelphia mint.

3) Check Buffalo Nickel values based on estimated grading and mint :
These are generally approximations of market values and retail coins prices, however a consenus of various price sources should be consulted in order to develop a "feel good price".

1923:
G($2.50), VG($3), F($5), VF($8), EF($15), AU($40)

1923-S:
G($9), VG($12), F($25), VF($150), EF($300), AU($350)

1935:
G($1), VG($1.50), F($2), VF($2.50), EF($4), AU($10)

1935-D:
G($1.50), VG($2.50), F($4), VF($10), EF($22), AU($45)

1935-S:
G($1), VG($1.50), F($2), VF($2.50), EF($4), AU($17)

Answer 2

Did you check to see if they had mint marks? It is on the buffalo (bison) side below the words five cents. The 1923 is common the 1923-S is more scarce. The 1923 is worth from $1.25 in grade good to $10 in grade extra fine. the 1923-S is worth $5.50 in good to $190.00 in extra fine. The buffalo must have full horns and have little wear in the grade extra fine. The 1935 as well as the S are worth in grade good .50 and $2.00 in extra fine. The D is a little scarcer at $1.00 in good to $15.00 in extra fine. The values are about what a dealer would pay.