Who The Best QB In The N.F.L?

Question

Tom Brady, Pit Manning, M Vick, D McNabb, Drew Brees, Big Ben, or Vince Young.

Answer 1

Tom Brady. 3 Rings. Always gives the Patriots a chance to get to the super bowl. You can argue Peyton Manning, but he has two pro bowl WRs to throw to while Brady is throwing to a bunch of scrubs when Deion Branch left.

Answer 2

If you are going by solely QB'ing meaning throwing the ball and making smart decisions on the field, oh and makes very few mistakes, Peyton Manning, even though he can not run with the ball at all (but honestly, does he need to). Overall, Peyton Manning and Drew Brees are tied, they can both throw the ball very well, they both make very few mistakes, and they both are very smart as far as football, like knowing when to try to avoid the sack, when to throw while getting hit, and when to just take the sack to avoid a fumble or interception. But you gotta give Big Ben some Credit, he's hasn't been playing as long as Peyton or Drew and he has already had some a serious injury early in his career

Answer 3

First of all, you cant have Mike Vick up there because its not potentially the best. You cant have "Big Ben" up there, because he had a horrible season and is overrated. You cant put Vince Young up there because he hasnt proven himself and hes still a rookie. McNabb didnt play this season, but you know hes great. You definitley need Carson Palmer up there, hes amazing.

Right now, at this very day, its Peyton Manning. He won the Super Bowl. But, if your talking about all active players, no matter when, Id say Tom Brady edges out Peyton Manning by a bit. He has a decent team and brought them to the AFC title game. He won 3 Super Bowls, 2 in a row. He is one of the best ever. On all around skill, you go with Peyton Manning though. The guy that should be the best is Mike Vick. He could be so amazing, but instead he chooses to get caught with a waterbottle full of weed in Miami Dade Airport. He hasnt improved at all since he came into the league, but he still has time to turn it around. Mike Vick could be a gamewinning MVP player, but he isnt playing at his full potential.

Answer 4

Anyone not on the Vikings roster....seriously our quarterback situation is horrendous! I like Jackson, I think he's gonna be great.....someday. But the fact we have no one behind center that will put fear into defenses, scares the crap outta me. I'm personally pissed off that we did not go after someone like Garcia via free agency, or even move up in last years draft and go after Leinart or Young.

Some people think we'll get Brady Quinn...but I see him as being another Daunte or Brad Johnson type. He can get the job done when needed..but when the big game comes...choke city.

If I have to pick ONE QB in the league, rather than everyone that isn't a Viking, I'll take Brees.

Answer 5

Peyton Manning, no quarterback has as much say in their play calls as he does. Plus, why else would his team listen to him when he said no visitors during Superbowl week and everyone had a strict and early curfew. The man is amazing, other are definitely close and competitive, but this guy will go down as the best ever. And no i am not a colt fan.

Answer 6

Each Quarterback is amazing at whatever they do. And with all these new and talented rookies that are coming up from colleges, almost the honor has to be given to Tom Brady, now I'm not a huge NE fan, but the guy has won three Super Bowls in 5 seasons. impressive by any measures.

Answer 7

Payton Manning

Answer 8

1. Brady
2. Manning
3. Palmer
4. Brees
5. Hasslebeck
6. Everyone else doesn't come close
15 or so. Roethlisberger
39. Grossman

Young will be number three under Palmer and Leinart in about six years.

Answer 9

Stat-wise:
Peyton Manning

My Opinion:
Tom Brady

Watch out for:
Donavon McNabb, i am an Eagles fan and while people laugh at McNabb but let me point out the 1 year he was healthy they went to the Superbowl.

Answer 10

Manning by end result of the season
Brees by the numbers.
Most underrated is Philip Rivers.