What is more annoying, singing off key, or singing off beat?

Question

My sister sings both off key and off beat...it gets annoying after a while.

Answer 1

Wow, talk about the lesser of two evils. I'd say off key. I'm a singer, and both of those irk me to no end.

Answer 2

If you’re like most people who dream of becoming a world-class musician or just love to sing, your goal is simple: you want to overcome your vocal barriers. You want to take your singing ability to the highest level.

And you know that across the world, more and more people are taking their voice to that next level.

Superior Singing Method - http://superiorsingingmethods.info/118/Video-Tips.html

But why do some of these ‘lucky’ singers seem to have amazing ability, perfect control, pitch, agility, confidence, and a huge vocal range – while you might still be struggling to improve your singing voice and have a masterful singing voice?

This is what makes the difference between a world-class singer and an average singer…

It’s all about how you practice and train your voice. Most ‘vocal improvement’ systems and techniques just give you a set of vocal exercises with NO direction and leave you on your own to figure out how to actually sing.

But at Superior Singing Method, I train you with a form of active vocal improvement to spark your inner singing ability, improve every aspect of your singing voice – which means that you will start singing the way you always dreamed while gaining a masterful control over your voice…with amazing power and a range that will let you hit every note with ease and confidence.

You’ll do this through a set of time-tested and highly refined vocal exercises that come together to train every aspect of your singing voice: a voice where you can sing with amazing pitch, better agility, more power, improved resonance and tone, and impress anyone who hears you sing.

The Superior Singing Method is like having a personal vocal instructor showing you exactly how your voice works, and how to work with each muscle group in your voice to get the results you want.

In Just 5 Minutes A Day, You Could Start Singing With Incredible Control, Power, Pitch, And More Freedom Than You Ever Imagined - http://superiorsingingmethods.info/118/Video-Tips.html

Over 10,000 Singers – Including Professionals, Recording Artists and Even Total Beginners – Have Used The Superior Singing Method To Experience Vocal Breakthroughs!

Answer 3

It's very possible to learn to sing well. You just need to know the right methods. Learn here https://tinyurl.im/aH6Zk Singing teachers will cost money and can be expensive so they're not for everyone. Singing can be learned so it's not an "either you have it or you don't" kind of thing. Whether you sound like crap or you're decent, I recommend this singing course. It's one of the best methods to learn to sing well in a short amount of time. It's all about using efficient techniques that work.

Answer 4

These days you can easily learn how to sing on the web . You can find here the best online singing video lessons:

http://www.goobypls.com/r/rd.asp?gid=541

The videos are very easy to follow and to my surprise extremely helpful even for advanced singers. For beginners I would have to say this is a gold mine. I was able to improve my singing, voice tone and range in just under two weeks and I am an advanced musician... Before I wanted to go to a singing teacher but that would have cost me over 1500 bucks .... every month! It's definitely too much for my possibilities! An online course is much cheaper, and I reached great results in a very short time! I strogly reccomend it to anyone that want to improve his/her singing skills and voice tune! I Hope it helps!

Answer 5

singing out of key and off the beat are both frustrating for us band members. sometimes the band can recover if the singer came into a verse too soon. but often it throws us into chaos. and often those who sing off key also have a poor sense of timing. unfortunately these people are not musicly gifted even with lessons. i have perservered in vain many times in the past, in the hope a singer will improve to no avail.

Answer 6

There both pretty annoying but I think off beat is worse...What really irratates me is when people try to sing a song but they dont know the words

Answer 7

Gosh, that's almost too close to call. I think singing off key would be worse.

Answer 8

So..
A good online course to improve your singing voice --> http://www.goobypls.com/r/rd.asp?gid=295
Bye Bye

Answer 9

off key is a little much

Answer 10

ok..so last nite? i had a chorus performance...

the alto section was

off key AND off beat...it sounded HORRIBLE!!! =[[

even during my double quartet =[[



but if i had to choose one to deal with? id rather have off beat...off key is 10x worse than off beat