Why telangana instead of a united Andhra?

Question

Hi,

I live in Europe, and i am from Hyderabad, though i am also from the Andhra district of Andhra Pradesh....
Now i was wondering why people want a seperate Telangana?
Cant we all live in peace together? I mean i am from Hyderabad, n i know lot of othesr people from the Andhra district who live and work in Hyderabad. So if Hyderabad becomes Telangana then there is no other major city in Andhra that can actually fund the state. We have all developed hyderabad and worked in it, it is so bad we suddenly have to give it away to another state we arent allowed to be in, our places wont be funded, n that is a total mess...
So actually i was wondering, why do u need a seperate Telngana? n why not share Hyderabad, like Punjab n Haryana do...?
This way everyone is happy n the city we all love will continue its rapid development without any prblems...
N plz dont say that (Vizag) Vishakpatnam is a major city... :|
I think it is not fair if a seprate telangana is frmed and Hyderabad isnt Andhra

Answer 1

Hmm..

1. People want separate state to get more money.
2. We all can live in peace, but politicians wont allow it.
3. Telangana is the loser in the divide definitely.
4. Yes, Hyderabad is a great loss to Andhra region.
5. But Andhra can fund itself with its cities. I doubt if Telangana can.
6. Sharing Hyderabad is impossible (only .01% chance)
7. Vizag is a big city, it has good future if separate state is given.
8. Hyderabad is not Andhra, it's true.

Don't worry. After separate state is formed, Andhra is not the loser definitely. Hyderabad will continue to have its global picture. And cities in Andhra will grow by leaps and bounds.

*Why waste 5 points asking same question in different places?*

Answer 2

To share Hyderabad on the lines of Chandigarh is a good one but, remember India is second largest democracy in the world and is ruled by those who want to be in power and gain all the political benefits no matter, even if the people who elected them remain no longer.
However, when we talk abt Hyderabad, the question also involves Telengana.
Why should the state should be seperated?
Is it necessary for the state to be seperated to acheive overall development of the state.
If there is any thing to be changed, then it is the ideologies of the people who represent their representatives and the representatives who get elected and then betray the people who elected them to achieve their selfish means.
Consider examples of Kerala, though small in area is completely developed state and we are nowhere even able to achieve the distinctions Kerala has achieved.
On the similar lines are Karnataka and Maharasthra, though Maha is also getting in to the same problem of Vidarbaha just because that it is the negligence the representatives who were being elected.
Why do u elect non-perfroming representatives and blame others.
I bet, if we start electing representatives in India or in any state based on a sole criteria that if the person being chosen will work for us or not, if he will remain unselfish in his service towards people and will he brave all odds in developing the region from where he was elected, keeping aside the party which is supporting him, then India will have consecutive hung assembiles and hung parliaments as not even a single party will gain majority. And this will also resolve the issues regarding the socio-economic development of Indians on overall.

I am sound a bit sarcastic, but I believe in putting forward those in which I believe.
I am sorry If I hurt anyones' emotions r sentiments.

Answer 3

As the region is under developed when compared to the other parts of Andra pradesh,feel to get separated to have a better developments& several issues are concerened too for the demand & some other regions too looking for separation from the states like maharastra .........& more over india is ruled by politicians,where people give enormous power to the leaders,till we cast the vote we are powerfull & after casting the vote we are power less..........some poltical parties says,small regions or states can be developed effectively & differences in the saying of the other parties.............
any way we are part of india irrespective of regions,concerns only in regional feelings........

all the best