Is Snape a good guy or a bad guy and is dumbledore alive?

Answer 1

Well, we dont really know where Snape's loyalties lie untill the 7th book. I say he's still good and him and Dumbledore arranged it. Dumbledore thought that Snape alive and trusted by Voldemort would be more important to the Order of the Phoenix than Dumbledore weak and possably a captive. So he told Snape that if it came down to it he had to kill him. Remember that argument Hagrid overheard between Snape and DD? And its not like Snape had much of a choice. He made the unbreadable vow to Narcissa Malfoy that he would protect Draco and kill Dumbledore if Draco can't. I think he really didnt want to kill Dumbledore but he had no choice. SNAPE IS GOOD!!!!!

Answer 2

If you want to know the ending of the 6th book, it makes you think Snape is bad and that Dumbledore is dead. After I got done reading it I got on to Yahoo Answers and several people were saying that in the end they think Snape will somehow save Harry and that he really isn't bad. It would be great, in my opinion, if Dumbledore wasn't really dead, but, I'm sure he is. As far as the actor that plays Dumbledore, the original actor Richard Harris played him in the first 2 movies, since then it has been Michael Gambon and I've never heard of him being Richard Harris's brother ...

Answer 3

Dumbledore is dead. This is not Star Trek where characters can be resurrected. If J. K. Rowling was even thinking of doing that, she'd probably bring back Sirius Black, not Dumbledore, because we don't have the body.

Snape is a very well fleshed out character. Like most real people, he has done bad things and he has done good things. He is neither good nor evil which makes him a hell of a lot more interesting.

We'll just have to wait to see which way he jumps in the final chapter.

Answer 4

To tell you the truth i thinik that snape is bad there are some good snape theroies That give some good reasons but i dont think that is good enough i think that snape is not good i mean he was a death eater even though he halped harry in the first book he killed dumbledore

And yes dumbeledore is dead if you don't belive me then go to mugglenet.com and go to debuncked rumors and jk said it herself that dumbledore is dead and he is not coming back

Answer 5

I'll tell you if no one else will... or just read the last chapter of the book. No, no look at the last chapter's intro picture and you tell me. (harry potter and the half blood prince)... ;) well then snape is still mysterious. I say that for this... he hesitated to do the job. there is an eye connection as thought they both [D and snape] have an understanding... this July the next book comes out! hurry up and reserve a copy!!!

Answer 6

i think in general snape is a good guy, he just gets the wrong impression. if you mean the actor of dumbledore, no. he is not alive, they had to use is brother in his place, but as dumbledore in the movie, yes, he is alive.

Answer 7

snape turns bad, or was bad all along. dumbledore dies in the sixth book, at the hand of snape.

Answer 8

interior the final e book you stumble on out that Dumbledore needed Snape to kill him because of the fact he became into loss of life besides and he did not choose Draco to do it. Snape became into additionally in love with Harry's mom and he became into certainly preserving Harry the entire time he became into at college. Snape in fact died for Harry interior the final e book.

Answer 9

If you

A) read the books

B) have the intelligence of a grapefruit

You will be able to answer the first question yourself. As for dumbledore, you'll have to keep reading.

Answer 10

a good one