Should i get my little girl circumcised?

Question

i read guys who are circumcised are more hygienic.
My indian friend is a doctor from pakistan and he said he can do it for me for a good price.
Is it worth it?

no, she has a vagina.

The doctor says it is a good idea for hygiene reasons.

sex is between two people who love each other. It should only be done for procreation.
Sex for pleasure is a sin and not halaal.

if it's not for hygiene, then why do women keep getting infections in their vagina's, this doctor says she won't get these infections. I'm doing it anyway this weekend, was just wondering what others opinions are.

Answer 1

you should be asking your lawyer

in several cases in the united states
female circumcism is considered to be abuse and mutilation

it has been so ruled because it is medicaly unnecessary, irrelevant to her hygene, and debilitating to her ability to achieve copulatory gratification in her adult life.

in the united states, if a doctor gets caught commiting such a surgery, they can lose their license to practice medicine.

so you may want to talk to the ama (american medical association) about the doctor that offered to perform the procedure to find out if their license is in fact valid in this country. also ask what their official ethical stand is on performing this surgery on a little girl.



HANG ON!!!!

what do you mean "she doesn't have a vagina"???
the very definition of a "girl" is to be born with a vagina.
if she has no vagina, you have bigger problems than circumcism to deal with.
do you have a hermaphrodite baby?

you need to make sure of the real gender of this child before you plan to start cutting things off!!!!!

you're either stupid or sick!
probably both.
foreign customs are so nasty.
leave that crap where you came from!

you're in america now, baby
in this counrty it's illegal to mutilate our citizens!


HANG ON AGAIN!!!!

who gives a crap about "halaal"? i understand the bit about sex being for procreation, the same mandate stands in many christian sects. but we don't cut our children up to ensure that they never enjoy themselves! procreation is meant to be enjoyable, in order to ensure the survival of our species.

you are a liar!

is it "halaal" for men to enjoy sex? no matter what you cut off, a man will still enjoy it. in this day and age, if you'tre so determined to hate sex, why not do in-vitro?

Answer 2

So you are saying you dont have sex for pleasure? Yeah right! If you do this to your LITTLE GIRL you will ruin her life, is that what you want? It is hygienic for boys but the idea of it being hygienic to girls is a myth to con people like yourself into degrading and controling women. This is 2007 and what you are considering in this country is illegal and classed as child abuse, you could end up in prison and losing your daughter for ever. Report this so called doctor before he ruins other peoples lives.

Answer 3

Defiantly no! It is not a hygenic problem for females and it is HIGHLY unnecessary to get one done for a emale. On a male it is highly necessary and not only is it for hygenic reasons but also for religious reasons too. I don't think that you should allow someone to do a thing like that to your daughter, it will be extremely painful and I can't understand why you would even want to consider it. You also have to look at the long term affects that this will have on your daughter, and as I have stated before there is no hygienic problem with a female and circumcising her wouldn't help at all it will only hurt.

Answer 4

Please do not do this. It is not necessary as hygiene for girls comes from properly cleaning the vagina and not the clitoris. Not only will it be a painful process for her (as most of the nerve endings are situated there), but it will cause her to never enjoy love making with her husband. Not to mention it is a very dangerous process. I know you want to do your best for your daughter, make her world better than yours would have been. However, I advise against it. The effects are just not worth it.
Good Luck.

Listen to me: there are no hygienic reasons for removing the clitoris of a female.... it is barbaric and sexist, designed to cause her pain and lack of pleasure later on. Female circumcision started not because of hygiene but because of the male belief that women should NOT enjoy sex. Do not do this to your child, if you love her... think of the long term effects. She'll hate you for it, trust me.

Answer 5

No u should not its barbaric and child abuse. She deserves to have sex without pain when shes grown up. If u think its so important then get urself done. Don't touch her OK?
You may feel sex should just be for reproducing but u have no right what so ever to do that to her. When shes grown up and married she deserves to be able to have sex in a loving way. Don't u have her circumcised.

Answer 6

Firstly, So your doctor is a indian and from Pakistan? Seriously?

2, Female Genital Mutilation don't happened in Pakistan, or even any countries in Middle East and South Asia. Its merely happening in North and West Africia (even some christians are doing it)

3. I don't know your religion but my religion Islam is against it. Islam is only asking males to do it, not female.

4. you sound like fake one, so f**K off. I would report polices to you!

Answer 7

i can't imagine how people can do this and torture their daughters, it should be banned- if your friend told u it should be done he doesn't have medical training, it has nothing to do with hygiene, i saw an interview a while ago of 2 women that experienced this, they both said the remember pain even though were very young- read and get educated (this is a good site about it)....
http://www.fgmnetwork.org/intro/fgmintro.html

Answer 8

people who tend to answer this question tend to be passionate with regards to the area. the people against it tend to answer maximum of solutions will say it incorrect to diminish a boy. there is scientific motives for slicing the boy. the lady there is not any data. it rather is basically cultural. it is likewise takes away feeling. people asserting it takes away feeling for the boy are absurd. Circumcised adult men experience sexual excitement alot so I doubt something became taken away. the people asserting the scientific data for slicing a boy is under fire are quoting examine finished via their a techniques left components. impartial components nonetheless help circumcision of boys for scientific motives. If it have been basically for non secular motives i could be against it, yet using fact it could basically help a boy than I help it. some people tend to think of with their thoughts basically and not seem at it logically and seem at each and every of the data from each and every of the components. Oh and you comparing it to slicing off a girl's breast are absurd. Breast are for feeding an toddler. It helps sustain existence. Boys that are decrease are much less possibly to have penial maximum cancers. in addition they have much less infections via a techniques. even whilst an uncircumcised boy keeps himself clean he remains extra possibly to have an infection.

Answer 9

do you want to take the joy of love making from this little girl how would you like it if you felt no pleasure when you had sex are you nuts and maybe the doctor is broke and needs your money?

Answer 10

When circumsising a girl you are effective removing her sex organ.It's simple really, would you like your penis removed completely? I don't think you would so stop being such an idiot and report this man because I think you will find that this practise is illegal and you could both go to prison for a long time!