Which of these three is my best choice in 2nd base?

Question

-José Vidro
-José Valentin
-Tadahito Iguchi

and need to choose one for my fantasy baseball team.

Answer 1

Ouch thats not very good for you....

I would either pick Vidro or Iguchi.

Vidro is better just an injury away from going to the DL "again"

Iguchi is decent and will get you 60 10 60 5 with a .275 average.

Iguchi is safe. Vidro could be good. both are not a very good option

Answer 2

Go with Iguchi, he is a consistent .280 hitter, playing in a HR friendly park he hit 18 in only 135 games. If he plays all 162 he could put up 20+ HR's and score over 100 runs. He will be the better option at 2B. He is on the rise and I put his production close to Uggla this year.
The only other forgotten player eligible at 2B that I have rated higher that I noticed is passed over on a lot of drafts is Chris Burke in Houston.
Valentin had a career year at .271 with 18 HR's but expect more around his usual .250.
Vidro's numbers have gone down every year since 2000 so I wouldn't predict a turn around 7 years later.

Answer 3

I would go with Jose Valentin, only because he will hit between 15-25 dingers , He is a bit older but keeps himself in great shape. Iguchi may give you a bit more SBs and a higher avg depends on what you need . Vidro would be a distant 3rd. Hope this helped TC. You may want to look to deal for a Kinsler or Barfield but you probably already know that, Good luck in your season.

Answer 4

Honestly, I like none of them, but if I had to choose, I'd choose Tad Iguchi. Why? Vidro and Valentin have both seen their primes pass them by. Iguchi still has another year or two left in the tank.

Answer 5

Um iguchi obviously. Valentin sint even worth a pick. he sucks. Unless your in a 20 team 30 man roster league, he shouldnt even be on a roster. Iguchi is actually a pretty good option. .280 15-20 80 100 with 15SBs to boot.

Answer 6

I'd choose the Gooch.