How does Aristotle's concept of happiness compare with Plato's concept of happiness?

Answer 1

Two issues must be addressed before attempting to answer this question. 1. Aristotle was a pupil of Plato, and as such likely held to many of the same philosophical notions - it may be different to find many definitive contrasts. 2. Plato's view of happiness and life generally was foundational in its formulation, that is, it held to certain moral maxims that were right regardless of utilitarian outcomes (take for example his esteem for Socrates death despite the practical option for avoiding punishment for that which should not have been deemed a crime in the first place). Aristotle, conversely, seems at times to side with the Sophists who held to far more hedonistic pursuits of happiness.

This second point is the area in which the greatest difference seems to exist, however Aristotle never gives us a definitive explanation of his position. Though I think this question is worthy of many pages, I think the most traction exists in Plato's absolute or foundational understanding of happiness "playing second fiddle" to one's moral obligation, while Aristotle seems to leave some room for debate in the way he seems to embrace individualism and knowledge. I

Answer 2

Plato thought that life living up to a reason is the highest good for men, this kind of life according to him, leads ultimate happiness. For Aristotle, happiness is that when man has realized himself(self-realization that is). For him, every single individual possesses different talents and abilities. If a man has realized his talents and abilities to the fullest, he has reached his ultimate happiness.

Answer 3

to each there own, my view of happiness is notthe same as yours. If money and wealth make you happy and having a loved on involved in my life makes me happy to each there own and how i get to my happy place will not be the same as for you to reach it