Is there one colts fan out there who will admit that brady is better than manning?

Question

I'd just like to know.

Answer 1

Brady would have won the Super Bowl if he were quarterback of the Colts also, and obviously has outplayed Manning most of the time in the big games.

Answer 2

I'm a 49ers and a University of Michigan fan. I have to say Manning is the better quarterback by far. Manning can take over a game and has much better stats and soon to be record breaking stats than Brady. Yes, he has two Pro Bowl wide receivers, but have you ever thought that maybe Manning just makes them look good and not the other way around. Not to mention Manning didn't have a clutch kicker like Brady had. Brady just had to get it past the fifty in reality and it would be a victory, Manning had to work a whole lot harder for his wins. Look at the win percentage, Manning dominates. Look at the QB stats, Manning dominates. Brady has won 3 Super Bowls, but Manning finally got his. Manning has won all those games without a defense. Brady has always had a defense to keep him in games. Peyton Manning will become better than Dan Marino and Joe Montana and that is a promise.

Answer 3

i'm no longer a Colts fan i'm a Vikings fan yet i choose to respond to this besides. Is Brady the final QB in the NFL? Yeah i think of so. might the Colts win with Brady at QB? i don't be attentive to approximately that. you ought to evaluate that Brady's recievers did no longer drop something (possibly as quickly as) against the Jags. shall we are saying they drop as many using fact the Colts receivers did as against the Jaguars or worse deflect passes to the protection. that provides them some 2d and longs and 0.33 and longs, possibly even a punt or interception or 2 - it alterations the sport - possibly the Jaguars even win that sport. Make it so no Colts recievers drop something or do no longer fumble. Mannings interceptions have been off tipped balls and that they dropped serious passes. The Colts surely beat the Chargers had the recievers been extra good. the different element is that no one places any warmth on Brady. If Brady had the warmth that Manning did, or Romo did he would not %. aside human beings like he did. You take a seat there and place all the credit on Brady yet you ought to comprehend that that's his group that makes him good too. the cases the place Brady has been compelled - and that has no longer been often he looks not extra useful than Manning, Romo, Garrard, Favre, Hasselbeck, etc. You take a seat on your intense horse now that the Patriots are having the season that they are and cock off yet the place have been you final 3 hundred and sixty 5 days? Statistically Manning has been extra useful in previous years. Did that make Manning extra useful or did he have extra useful recievers? do no longer throw stones once you reside in a tumbler abode. The Patriots won't continuously be this good - bear in concepts that. Edit- particular it become with none type what so ever that Colts followers booed that female in the PPK contest. this is incorrigible. yet have you ever listened to Pats followers at cases or any followers relatively for that remember. I certainly have seen and heard some exceedingly rotten issues mentioned and completed to childrens at Pats video games too. Colts followers only did it on television the place every person observed it. Does it make it spectacular - heck no. Are the Pats followers harmless $^%& no!!! And as far as Brady having "nameless" recievers in the previous, they weren't slouches - even final 3 hundred and sixty 5 days. have been they Moss? - no of path no longer, yet Deion branch isn't a slouch. Did you forget approximately how he performed in the great Bowls?

Answer 4

No one with half a brain will admit that, especially a Colts fan. I appreciate the first poster's honesty though.

The rings only tell part of the story. Sure he has two more than Peyton, but the Patsies had better all around teams and a lot more luck. The numbers overall tell the best story. And by the time these two retire, Manning will have that many rings. Maybe not the next two years, but eventually.

Answer 5

I am Ravens fan. I hate the Colts and I hate the Patriots. I will tell you that no Colt fan is going to say Brady is better than Manning because of Mannings numbers, just like most Pats fans wont say Manning is better than Brady because of his rings and playoff record. So to answer your question, no.

My 2 cents- I like Brady better, nothing against Manning but Brady is so much better looking.

Answer 6

I like the Patriots and Brady but I think Manning is better than Brady.

Answer 7

Well, Manning is certainly better at using birth control....... or he's just Gay...... As far as the QB position, well let's see.... Brady has 3 super bowls, manning has 1.... manning has 2 pro bowl wide outs, Brady has none......

My opinion is manning has the better weapons at his disposal, but Brady has accomplished much more with an inferior supporting cast. This used to be an easy argument, but manning is closing the gap on ol Tommy boy.... Still I have to say Brady is the best QB in the NFL.

Answer 8

Well...I'm a fan of neither team, but I have to comment because it's my nature to do so. Manning is probably the best QB in the NFL talent wise, without a doubt. Nobody even comes close. But when it comes to just putting games on your shoulders and carrying your team through it, however ugly the win may be, Tom Brady's your man for the job. They both have their upsides, but Manning seems like more of just a pure QB while Brady just seems like a winner..period.

Answer 9

Not me. Why does it bother Patriot fans so much? I think most Colt fans would agree the Patriots have had much better TEAMS than the Colts. That's been proven.

Answer 10

the only thing that Brady MIGHT be better at is getting out of a collapsing pocket, and that's not great because over time manning (arguably the best quarterback ever to play the game) has also learned to do this, not only that he is so in sync with his team that he is able to make a huge play out of nothing with his audible abilities he also has the best offense ive ever seen on one team at a time so no Brady is not better and the only reason he has more rings is DEFENSE WINS CHAMPIONSHIPS, and until this year we have not had a defense.