Do you think DUI repeated offenders should got to a rehab facility instead of taking AA classes?

Question

I think someone who gets more than 1 DUI definitely has a problem. If so, I think to be sentenced to a rehab clinic would be far more suitable then to do community service, or just a few days in the county jails. They need to get rid of the source of the problem. Drinking. Do you agree?

Answer 1

in tennessee if you have more than 1 DUI you have the option of going to a 28-day drug and alcohol treatment center. its called the ADAT program. (alcohol and drug abuse treatment) but you have to ask the judge for it, and it usually the time you spend in rehab counts for jail time, otherwise you get a minimum 45 days in jail (for 2nd DUI) after completing treatment you are put on probation. probation requirements are that you attend AA or NA meetings, attend drug and alcohol classes, and follow up with outpatient treatment (counseling, meetings, aftercare at rehab facility) so there is a lot being done to prevent drinking and driving, however sobriety is a choice and not everybody is stong enough to conform to the lifestyle changes getting and staying sober requires. i think community service is important also for DUI offenders, or any offender for that matter. only a combination of jail, rehab, aftercare, probation, and a desire to stay clean and sober will help someone who has commited multiple DUI's.

Answer 2

Anyone that's had a drinking problem knows you can't force them to get help until they're ready. Personally.....I don't like the idea of court ordered AA meetings because it's compromises the anonymity of the people trying to do something. Maybe AA meetings in jail. I agree.....a few days in jail does nothing. Less time in exchange for re-hab or meetings is just a bartering tool that rarely works. Plus.....way too many of the re-habs they send them to aren't much more than a holding place with a few sessions. They need to feel there is no option, no easy way out, but to quit drinking and unfortunatly many just don't.
They need a minimum of 30 days without alcohol to get through the physical withdrawl. After that is personal work and that is when AA and therapy can help if they want to change. I don't know if they have developed any drugs that they could mandate that would make them sick as a dog if they drank or not.
It's difficult to find the 1 solution for everyone. A persons bottom is different for everyone. I met one woman who's bottom was stealing money from the offering plate at church. Others are still drinking when they're homeless, sick or in jail for murder. But you're right......gotta get rid of booze to find out what's left to work with underneath.

Answer 3

No Rehab too expensive They all hate AA as I do Make them pick up trash along the roads for a month in chains Never had a DUI myself

Answer 4

confident.Judges ought to be extra durable on repeat offenders.i think of there ought to be extra durable outcomes for FIRST time offenders.consistent with threat then one could think of two times and not elementary approximately committing a 2d or third offense.i'm no longer proud in any respect to confess that i've got racked up six D.U.I.s interior the thirty six years i've got been using.My first one became into in '87.My final in '05.In all,it somewhat is fee me extra desirable than $seventy 5,000.00 in fines and restitution,a marriage,2 properties and intensely virtually 4 years of freedom in six diverse jurusdictions. i know that if i could have won a harsher penalty for my first one and extra coaching i could have viewed replace ability of transportation. I even have yet to get at the back of the wheel because of the fact my final offense.in general because of the fact DMV says i'm no longer able to(till I finished an 18 month educational direction) and in section because of the fact I,ve grown up and found out that i do in contrast to penal complex.and that i additionally know that it somewhat is purely incorrect to drink andchronic.i'm relatively happy that I by no ability led to anybody any harm. confident! Judges ought to be extra durable on repeat D.U.I. offenders!

Answer 5

Yep but only if they are forced to pay for it themselves. People who drink and drive drunk should have the worst possible things happen to them if they are repeat offenders.