How come hearing a person talk does not reveal whether or not they have a good singing voice?

Answer 1

Vocal characteristics are a funny situation. Many fine singers sound entirely different when they speak. I think it has to do with the different manipulation of the vocal chords and the diaphragm. As some singing teachers say, the voice is an "instrument", and the singer must learn how to use it as such. Actors know that emoting (speaking on the stage) is different from natural speech as well.

Many fine people who are pleasant when they speak just don't have the vocal range to sing (not even a full octave); while others can sing almost three octaves ! And others are just "tone deaf"--they just cannot differentiate one note from another, and cannot recreate the note with their voice, no matter how hard they try.

Each of us has different gifts. One singer can sing a soft ballad, while another can sing an operatic aria; but the skill very rarely transfers outside of their particular form of music. Few opera singers can sing pop and jazz; few jazz singers would even attempt opera. They are just two different sets of skills and techniques.

Answer 2

John B has given you a lot of good information.
To make a long story short: when we speak, we generate less air pressure to send through our vocal cords, and the pitch / sound of our voice is in a comfortable range. ( Unless you're doing cartoon voices!) When we intensify the air pressure, like yelling or screaming, the pitch / sound will probably go up, as a reaction to the increased air flow.
Speaking gives absolutely no indication of what will happen in the specialized area of singing, where not only air pressure, but the use of the larynx ( voice box) is slightly different.
Also, when we speak, we generally want to get our point across, and take very little time to articulate our vowels and consonants. When we sing, this becomes of great importance, as this becomes the basis for that classical sound.
the potential for singing is most every voice, like the potential for track running in every pair of legs. It's how and what you train that makes the difference.
By the way, most " tone deaf" people are not. they merely lack the training to hear discriminately. The actual number of people with congential amusia is very low indeed.

Answer 3

Really just a stab in the dark, but don't people use different vocal cords for speaking and singing? Maybe that's why. Don't know.

Answer 4

definite I do. each and all of the time. Incessant chattering that may not end till I consciously tell them to end. in basic terms on and on and on. maximum of messages. maximum of comments. maximum of cries for help. that is overwhelming. while i'm mendacity in mattress on occasion, in basic terms as i'm approximately to glide off, I hear somebody call my call (i'm not sure if that is in my head or in the room) on occasion i'm able to decipher between the indoors and exterior, yet lots of the time i'm focusing lots on what's being reported I lose sight of it. besides- continually my call first- and diverse voices. and that i'm getting the sensation that as quickly as some voices say my call, they're saying it for the 1st time, like somebody in basic terms informed them my call and that they call it out excitedly to verify if it works. The wellbeing care provider gave me a prescription as quickly as. I under no circumstances took it. i do no longer think of i'm loopy. i'm able to functionality in basic terms wonderful in society.

Answer 5

... because when you talk you don't use your voice as a musical instrument- the vocal chords are relaxed... whereas when you sing you use your vocal chords like an instrument.

Answer 6

coz unless its a natural talent, singing is practiced and improved but your real voice need not be practiced coz its what you really sound like

Answer 7

because singing is just speaking in tone or pitch, and if you are a good singer depends on your ability to use tone/pitch etc.

Talking doesn't use tone or pitch, so you cannot know what they are capable of

Answer 8

when hearing a person speak at normal levels they're not working their vocal chords to much, makin it more hoarse