Who is the better Quarterback?

Question

Peyton Manning of the Colts or his brother Eli Mannings of the Giants? Plus, Troy Aikmen or Joe Montana? Explain why!

Answer 1

Peyton is a much better QB than Eli. Besides that he has several more years of experience, there is the fact that he just won the Super Bowl and Eli can't even win a playoff game. Eli gets rattled easily while Peyton always seems to be in control of the game.

As for Montana or Aikman, I would have to say Montana simply because he is one of the greatest winners of all-time and he won so many Super Bowls. He always came up big in the playoffs. Aikman was also a good QB, but his career was cut short by concussions. Montana had more longevity and was a more accurate passer.

Answer 2

Peyton is easliy better than Eli. He is a much more experienced QB. Even without the superbowl title, Peyto is the better Manning just because he's been there longer and I think he just has more of a natural gift than Eli.

I pick Joe Montana over Troy Aikmen. Troy was good, but Joe had a more successful career and again I think he just had more of the stuff quarterbacks are made of.

Answer 3

I hate Peyton Manning but he is better then Eli I rather throw a pick instead of getting sacked Manning As far as Montana and Aikmen I have to go Joe all the way I hope helped you.

P.S Go Chiefs!!!

Answer 4

Peyton Manning. I believe that Eli is hype because of Peyton and Archie Manning. The Colts system built around Peyton and for his career Peyton has overall QB rating of 94.4, 64% pass/completion rating, 37,586 total passing yards, and 275 touchdowns. P.Manning rookie year was the only year were he had more INT than touchdowns, 26TD/28INT. However, he threw for over 3000 yards and his passing completion was above 50%. Eli rookie season, he was below 50% pass completions, and only played 9 games. The following two seasons, including this past year, his passing completions were just above 50%, (52.8 and 57.7). He threw more touchdowns that INTS...but this is a Giants team that is timid about centering its offense around Eli. Before this question can be asked, give Eli five more seasons before asking which Manning brother is better.

Troy Aikman (not Aikmen) or Montana...I would say Montana because he always had those amazing comebacks. Montana had 273 Touchdowns, over 40,000 passing yards, and a QB rating of 92.3. Aikman has above 32,000 passing yards and only 165 touchdowns with a pass rating of 81.6. Both have their fare share superbowl victories and spotlight during their respected decades...Montana during the 80s' and Aikman in the 90s'.

Answer 5

Peyton Manning is way better than his brother Eli, even in college he was. He has the stats to prove to be one of the best to ever play the position, has league MVP's, Super Bowl MVP, and finally got his ring. This guy can flat out play quarterback and is surely going to the Hall of Fame when his record breaking career is over.

Joe Montana is better too. This guy is the only player with three Super Bowl MVP awards. Plus, he has won the big game four times. He has great stats and really only had one talented receiver in that of Jerry Rice. Aikman was good, but no Joe Montana. Montana is argued as the best quarterback to play, even over Dan Marino.

Answer 6

Peyton has a few more years experience with a better O-line and better receivers. I'm torn between Troy and Joe...both Hall of Fame quarterbacks, both superbowl winners. I think I'll say Joe Montana because he did it before Troy. That's the best I can do. Have a nice day.

Answer 7

Peyton Manning is better then Eli Manning and has the stats and championship ring to back it up. Joe Montana is better then Troy Aikman because Joe Montana has the better stats.

Answer 8

Troy Aikman or Joe Montana over the Mannings any day. Both Mannings are highly overrated and unlike Joe and Troy have 1 Superbowl between them.

Answer 9

Peyton over Eli by a mile & Joe over Troy by a fraction of an inch.

Answer 10

1. Joe Montana
2. Peyton Manning
3. Troy Aikman
476. Eli Manning

You know who had probably the best mechanics was Jeff George. His attitude stunk, and he was too egotistical to ever be a good quarterback, but his throws were just perfection to watch!