What is your favorite judge on american idol?

Question

I like Paula.. She is sweet and has a great opinion.

Answer 1

Simon. He seems very objective no matter if he likes that contestant personally or not. And he's always straight up with his opinins. I also saw him earlier on Access and he said the pix from the one girl on the internet were disgraceful. I think all 3 judges were aware of them last week and really seemed to say America should be judging on singing not how slutty someone can be.

Answer 2

I would have to say Simon because he actually gives them good advice. Paula is my least favorite... she trys to be on everyone's side when really she needs to be telling them what they need to improve on. One of my favorite parts of the show is the critisism from Simon!

Answer 3

Paula only because she is sweet in what ever she says.

Answer 4

i would have to say simon .paula:she is to nice and easy
simon:to hard but he is the one who made the show nayhow
randy:kind of both .but paula she has to be so nice and doesn't even tell teh truth how she feel sometimes cuz she don't want to hurt anybody feelings

Answer 5

Simon. Definitely. He gives it to the contestants straightforwardly. You have what it takes or you don't. Randy and Paula are too soft I think.

Answer 6

I'd have to say Simon. He's the only one I really listen to. Randy is too neutral and Paula is difficult to listen to...she rambles.

Answer 7

Simon...

1. he's honest.
2. he's truthful.
3. he doesn't sugar coat things.
4. hot.

Answer 8

Simon- he tells it like it is....

He is not on drugs and he doesn't end any sentance with dog

Answer 9

Simon
i don't like the other two

Answer 10

paula or randy