URGENT Fantasy Help?

Question

Barrett
Cano
Pujols
Beltré
Tejada
Delmon Young
Ordonez
edmonds
thome
stevie drew
milton bradley
eckstein
uribe
inge

smoltz
wang
kenny rogers
verlander
burnett
hoffmann
dotel
procter

Should I make this trade?
Sizemore
Halladay
Helton
for
Pujols

Answer 1

I am assuming you have Pujols based on what you posted. The other guy is offering a ton and based on the rest of your roster I would make this deal in a heartbeat. You give up the best player no doubt but you get 3 top quality players in return including a premier outfielder. Dont pay attention to the people who say Helton is in decline, he got extremely sick in spring training last year and lost 20 pounds. He never regained the strength and played at less than 100%, also take a minute to look at his 2nd half numbers and then you will see how much he ISNT in decline. I won 6 of 8 yahoo leagues last year simply because I take the time to look past numbers or star power, pay attention and make the deal, you will be a far better team if you do. Then offer a starter for a closer....Wang or Rogers, both will get wins and decent ERAs but not much else. And cut Proctor and either Uribe or Eckstein as the other 2 players in the trade (to keep your roster at the right number).

Answer 2

No, don't make the trade.

If you're gonna give up Pujols, you better make sure you're getting players that will significantly upgrade many categories. I'm sure he was your first pick so you better get players of first or 2nd round caliber back.

First off, I wouldn't want Helton - he's not much more than a doubles hitter. Sizemore is good but can he carry your fantasy team? Doubtful. Halladay is fantastic when he's playing but unfortunately freak injuries keep attacking him. It's unfair but he is a major injury risk.

Furthermore, receiving 3 players for 1 would likely mean you're gonna have to drop 2 of them or players on your team. Do you really want to do that? I'd be willing to make the trade after the season starts and some of the dust settles, but not now.

Answer 3

No. Pujols will form the points on your team and Halladay gets hurt a lot, Helton is on the decline, and Sizemore isn't a sure thing. Plus, you would have to release 2 good players to make that trade.

Answer 4

No I don't think so. you don't want to give up Pujols. If I beelieved Helton would be his old self I would say yes, but I don't. Don't trade Pujols.

Answer 5

Yes, grab Pujols. Helton is def on the decline, i love halladay and sizemore is only average in my opinion. pujols is worth way more than those three!

Answer 6

are you kidding me dont make that trade. Never trade 3 players for 1. Sizemore is probably going to be MVP this year in the AL. And hallady is an amazing pitcher with helton is a career .317 hitter. Your crazy if you make that trade.

Answer 7

Yeah I'd do it. Try and get a better outfielder than Sizemore while your at it. Someone who really wants Pujols just might make a stupid move.

Answer 8

Yes

Answer 9

keep Pujols! - todd shriber

Answer 10

yea