Do you believe Sirius is dead?...Dumbledore?

Question

I only think Dumbledore is really dead cause JKR said so 3 times.waaah!

But I dont think Sirius is dead! I think that theres something up with that archway thing with the curtain. Also I've never seen JKR say that Sirius is dead, she's said Dumbledore's dead but I havent seen her say Sirius is dead.

I've heard that the Mirror Sirius gave Harry is gonna be important in the last book, what d'you think?

Answer 1

SIRIUS IS NOT DEAD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

JK. never SAID he REALLY WAS DEAD....

I get so angry when people say that he is dead.

No one has found Sirius's body( obviously it's in the veil) but the characters just guess that he is dead....and I think harry will save Sirius or Sirius will come and try to save Harry or Sirius will come to get revenge on his cousin, Bellatrix!!!

Answer 2

Like you, i think dumbledore is actually dead, and i also think that sirius will have a part in the 7th book. there is something about the archway that was never explained to harry or anyone when sirius first "fell through". the just told him that he was gone, but didnt say where he went, or how it works or anything like that. i would bet that he helps harry and the rest of the D.A. defeat voldemort in the 7th book.

Answer 3

Well Harry can still communicate with Dumbledore through the portrait in the headmasters office, but since he isnt going to go back to hogwarts, maybe not. As for Sirius, he's definately dead, but maybe in the final battle between Harry and Voldemort he'll cheer Harry on through Priori incantem like in the fourth book.....who knows?!! We just have to wait a few more months to find out!!!!(yaaaaaaaaaahhhhhh!!!! :D )

Answer 4

Of course he's NOT DEAD !!!!

It's his master plan to fool all of us muggles.
Here are the clues that show Dumbledore (APWBD) is alive

Albus Percival Wulfric Brian Dumbledore Lives !

http://www.johndasfundas.blogspot.com/2007/02/albus-dumbledore-lives.html

Clues showing dumbledore did not die : http://johndasfundas.blogspot.com

Blog's article


http://www.johndasfundas.blogspot.com/2007/02/albus-dumbledore-lives.html

Dumbledore's big chill
Odo the Hero
Let's All Play Dead Together
Fawkes doesn't try to save Dumbledore
The Flying Avada Kedavra
Don't Point That At Me Unless You Mean It
Fawkes' Lament
Anyone Seen Dumbledore's Wand Lately?
No Body, No Crime
Caution: Dumbledore Is Flammable

All the clues explained in detail.

http://johndasfundas.blogspot.com/2007/02/albus-dumbledore-lives.html

Answer 5

Maybe Dumbledore pulled an Shinobi trick and switched himself with a mannequin.jk the mirror,yeah possibly im not going to take any guesses or discuss the book with anybody cause i want to be shocked at series end.Back to Dumbledore.Just because she mentioned that he's dead three times(is that an Author thing,three mentions and your dead?)doesn't mean anythng.I think Dumbledore is alive,it's like Sylar and Suresh on Heroes,Sylar had one last trick up his sleeve.Either that or Dumbledore bieng dead in the Deathly Hollow will be an important key factor.Let's wait or the book.

Answer 6

i think that they are both dead. sirius is dead for a long time, i dont think that he ll play a great role at the book and dumbledore is dead too. the important thing will be sirius' house, i think that his mother and brother kept there some horcruxes.

Answer 7

I don't think either of them are dead. If you want to check out this site:http://www.redhen-publications.com/Loyaulte.html
It goes into detail that Snape and Dumbledore were working together before the prophecy was made. It's kind of long though...Enjoy!
p.s I also think the mirror is important.

Answer 8

I think Sirius is coming back, but I don’t think Dumbledore is coming back. In addition, I think she is going to kill Harry off so no one can continue the series.

Answer 9

I don't think dd is dead. I'm not sure if Sirius is dead or not that was a mysterious curtain.

Answer 10

i agree! THAT WOULD BE SO COOL!