Fantasy Baseball trade?

Question

What do u think of this trade? MY pitching is strong so I dont really have to worry about carpenter because i already have Zambrano and Kazmir

i get:
Tejada
Smoltz
Dan Wheeler

for
Bill Hall
K-Rod
Chris Carpenter

Answer 1

No way dude.... your giveing up a top pitcher and a Top Closer for TJ. Smoltz is good but is getting older and team is getting weaker. I would do Carpenter strait up for Tejada. or if you want to add Hall in you can. but this trade is horrible

Answer 2

If holds count in your league I'd say it's a great trade...Tejada & schmooltz are perpetuals, & Wheeler is one of the best 8th inning men in the game (which might translate to saves if Lidge can't get his stuff together...)

Hall & Carpenter could go either way...K Rod is always good, but you have to give to get I s'pose...

Answer 3

I would say pull the trigger, Tejada is well, Tejada, Smoltz could be a #1 on most teams, and with him as your 2/3. If you have another solid closer definetly do it, because that would be the only cause for concern.

Answer 4

It's a good trade. I don't think you should trade Carpenter, but to get Tejada and Smlotz, it's worth it. I don't tlike Dan Wheeler, he's probably not so great to have on your team, but overall, it's an ok trade.

Answer 5

smart trade, smoltz is a little less better then chris, tejada had a down year but will bouns back up with better hitting support, k-rod is a great pitcher but will only get u SV one catigorie while smoltz and tejada will get u all of the catigories

Answer 6

dont do it,, Kasmir will be ok w/ era and Ks, but not wins,, Keep Carpenter.

Answer 7

Ouch, you got ripped off BIG TIME!