Which QB will be the best 5 years from now?

Question

Vince Young, Brady Quinn, JaMarcus Russel, Matt Leinart, Alex Smith, Eli Manning, J.P. Losman, or Jay Cutler.

Also add Philip Rivers and Tony Romo to the list.

Answer 1

Vince Young. He already went to the Pro Bowl as a rookie and he knows how to win (Texas 06 Rose Bowl Champions). He can do it with his arm and his legs.

Answer 2

I think J.P. Losman is a very good player, but he is at a horrible team. Vince Young is good, but I think that a running quarter back in this league will not last very long. Look at Michael Vick. Matt Leinart or JaMarcus Russel is my pick. Mat Leinart has a very good pro style and JaMarcus is a freak of nature.

I think people are thinking Vince Young is too good. I mean in Michael Vick's first starting year he made it to the playoffs. But now he might be done. No quarter back that runs a good deal can make it in this league. Its a fact. He will not be able to make it. The problem is the NFL is too fast and too strong. He will become hurt and lose his ability to run, and his passing is not good enough. Beware of the running QB.

Answer 3

I like Vince Young but I think he is gonna be third.
Alex Smith and J.P. Losman are definitely improving and Losman is doing a good job considering the place he is in, both physically and mentally.
But to tell you the truth, Philip Rivers is going to be phenomenal now that he has shown everyone, especially the Giants, that he is excellent and probably the best QB of his class, and way more than Eli Manning.

Answer 4

If you're talking stat-wise, then probably Alex Smith. He improved a lot this year, and yes Frank Gore did carry that offense, but Smith did exactly what he needed to do and their run game will only help to open up the pass game. All he needs is a few good receivers.

If you're factor in those things that can't be measured in stats, definitely vince young. He probably will never have unrealistic stats like peyton manning, but he does have excellent leadership, which is something that you cannot teach. He's also a dual threat, and unlike other scrambling qbs (MICHAEL VICK) he can throw well in the pocket and on the run.

Answer 5

Vince Young for sure, and you forgot another QB from that age of Manning and Losman, Philip Rivers.

Young And Rivers are gonna be the best

cutlers gonna be a bust

Answer 6

Quinn will suck. losman and eli aren't that good. ROMO is over-rated. Cutler, Leinart, Young, Smith will be great ones. And lets see what Rivers can do without L.T. probably not too much. so i say he is OVERRATED also. I'll tell you somone you should add to the list------- MATT SCHAUB. once he gets out of the ATL or Vick leaves he will be vicious.

Answer 7

Vince Young, if he can stay healthy and work on actually be a QB intstead of a RB (19 TDs lats season, 12 passing, 7 rushing) and cut down on his pics (13) he will have a few rings by the time hes done.

Answer 8

Ben Roethlisberger, but I'd have to agree with the dude who said to keep an eye on Matt Schaub, if he ever gets a chance. I think he could really be a breakout quarterback. Bold statement saying Eli Manning will be out the league in five years.

Cheers!

Answer 9

Phillip Rivers without a doubt. Tony Romo won't even be in the league five years from now. It's even possible that Eli Manning won't be either.

Answer 10

Vince Young because he is different than any other person on there except for JaMarcus Russel. Russel needs to be in the NFL before i make my decion on him