Possible Scenario: Osama Bin Laden captured?

Question

Take the following possible scenario:

- American troops arrested key leaders in the Al-Qaeda network in Pakistan. Among the captured included Osama, and Ayman al Zwahri.
- Then Pakistani forces somewhat loyal to the Islamist movement claimed jurisdiction and placed the leaders under Pakistani arrest/protection.

The US want to extract the leaders for a trial, but religious leaders in Pakistan don't want them released without a guarantee of a fair trial.

1. What could we do to convince them to give us the al-Qaeda leaders? (special ops is out of the question, economic incentives? help from international org?)
2. Where would we try them? (American court? UN international court? EU court?)
3. Once we choose where to try them, what can we actually charge them with? (Piracy?)

Pakistan receives almost 1 billion dollars in aid annually. Pakistan fears that their temporary alliance will go away once bin laden has been captured.

Does anyone have a viable policy/solution for this?

No crap answers please. My class has been put forth this question, and I was hoping for some input on what are the best choices

Answer 1

"We're whalers on the moon
we carry a harpoon
but there ain't no whales
so we chopped our tails
As we sing our whaling tune."
I have no idea.

Answer 2

The Bush clique do not want Osama captured alive, because he would be put on trial. Then the facts would come into view about the long cozy relationship between the Bush clan and the Bin Laden family.

Also, the removal of Bin Laden from his status as the poster boy for terrorism would weaken George Bush by removing the boogieman he uses to scare the American people into surrendering their liberties.

However, Osama is now old and sick and likely to die soon. Watch Bush then suddenly discover a new threat to scare the American people.

Fidel Castro stayed in power for forty years by using the threat of the dread Yanquis to keep his people subjugated. Hitler used the Jews as his "threat". Bush needs somebody to label as the stereotype terrorist figure so he can manipulate the American people in the same way. When it's no longer Osama then a new bad guy will be found so we have someone to fear and hate while we grovel to Emperor George the Decider.

Answer 3

The Bush clique do now not decide on Osama captured alive, for this reason of actuality he must be placed on trial. Then the information ought to alter into seen on the subject rely of the long gentle courting between the Bush prolonged kin and the Bin laden kin. additionally, the removing of Bin laden from his status for this reason of actuality the poster boy for terrorism ought to weaken George Bush via removing the boogieman he makes use of to scare the american people into surrendering their liberties. in spite of the actuality that, Osama is now previous and unwell and specific to die right away. Watch Bush then with out be conscious hit upon a sparkling danger to scare the american people. Fidel Castro stayed in potential for 40 years via utilizing the prospect of the dread Yanquis to maintain his people subjugated. Hitler used the Jews as his "danger". Bush desires somebody to label for this reason of actuality the stereotype terrorist verify so he can handle the american people indoors the comparable way. on an analogous time because it somewhat is now now not Osama then a sparkling undesirable guy may be have been given here in the process so we've somebody to agonize and hate on an analogous time as we grovel to Emperor George the Decider.

Answer 4

Funny how this scenario could have been averted if Clinton would have just taken him out when he had the chance. Actually, I don't think that Musharref doesn't want anything to do with trying Bin Laden. He hopes Bin Laden dies in the arrest attempt.

Answer 5

Your fantasy has a big problem right in the beginning . The U.S. does NOT give up prisoners to anybody !!!
Bin Laden would not live to see the light of day !!

Answer 6

1- UN backing and a written statement on how they will be tried, their rights, what punishments they face. and we'll keep giving them some money

2-UN court

3- Crimes against humanity, war crimes