should teachers scream at students?

Question

when teachers are angry at students for being naughty and they yell at them to get out, i think its ok but what about when they haven't completed work??? id like your opinions please

Answer 1

If teachers are supposed to set an example I cannot see the validity of them screaming at all.
Screaming is,in itself,demonstrative that the teacher has failed in their attempt to rationalize and/or keep control of a given situation.
It is not a sign of maturity and is a poor example to set.
If a student fails to complete a homework assignment or other set work then it should be explained to the child that it was in their own interests to complete it not the teacher's.
Any teacher attends school in the capacity of providing the opportunity for the student(s) to learn.
If the student chooses to decline taking up that facility then it is not the teacher's loss so why the extreme reaction?
This teacher is obviously stressed out.
It was a matter simply for her to inform the parents of a younger child or else note it on the end of term report in the case of a senior student.
Teachers generally should conduct themselves in a manner that encourages their charges to behave likewise in return.
That is both education and maturity

Answer 2

If they are like under 10 I understand how it feels when they dont listen to you. I'm only 19 but during my recent school holiday I became a primary school assistant for 2 weeks to stand in for a teacher that was sick, & it got really crazy sometimes. Personally I feel that shouting is indeed a bad way to respond to bad situations, but if the students like you in general they wouldnt mind if you do it every now and then.
I give each & every one of them three chances -- only when they use up all 3 would I start raising my voice. If they have work they simply refuse to do, I'd get them to stay back after class & we'd do it together before I allow them to leave.

Answer 3

It is not necessary for any teacher to scream at any child unless the child is faced with a life or death situation. For example walking in front of a moving vehicle (possibly at recess.) or something similar. In my opinion screaming is when you are losing control and are not using your creativity. It's also teaching the child to scream at others for lack of a better resolution. Maybe instead it's time for another parent teacher conference (and I know sometimes that's difficult to do.) Or simply have the child face the consequences of a very low grade for not completing his/her assignment.

Answer 4

NO! That is a really bad way to deal with students. Just talk to them in a soft and in the same way demanding voice. Dont scream or shout or hurt the student. You need to earn respect from the student so the student wont do bad things, you need to earn their respect too.

Answer 5

well screaming at the students is really uncalled for. coz if you are a teacher you should command an authority. and that is an earned respect. i mean if u say go out in a firm tone student will follow you if the students respects you. you dont have to scream. what will u get when u scream? nothing except rage from the students in return.

Answer 6

Those people that answer the questions above probably have not taught before or have only taught very good and obidient students -those in the top school and top classes.

Ideally as a teacher one should not.... but.....

If you do have to teach in the normal stream or the last class in the school you will understand the frustration the teachers have over the class. these kids are in school because they have to and not they wanted to. so they will do anything to make their live fun but the teachers' live miserable. teachers have a role to play - to teach and complete the syllabus so that these students can sit for their national examples like GCE O Level and N levels.

We are stressed out because the students dun care ! and they are not making the classroom condusive for learning. noise level is high and what do you want us to do ? be patient with them ? 1 teacher verses 40 noisey bunch, and the boss is watching as well...... why is the syllabus not done? are they prepared ? etc

we dun like to scream at them - but we need to in order to bring them back to where they belong - as a student in a classroom to learn......

have a heart for us......

Answer 7

I don't think that screaming is a mature response to a bad situation. Since the teacher needs to be the adult in the situation or the one in charge they should set the example and be in control of the situation without screaming-it doesn't matter what has happened.

Answer 8

Screaming, no. Raising your voice, yes. Have I yelled at some of my students (high schoolers) before that wouldn't stop being really disruptive and wouldn't listen to me no matter how patient I was or how many chances I gave them? Yes.

Answer 9

NO. Its wrong. Teachers were probably taught ways to deal with this type of thing in college. Shouting at students does nothing for their confidence or development especially in front of a class of their friends and other classmates.

Answer 10

of route, instructors might want to no longer scream or yell at scholars. instructors should be experienced in lecture room administration and performance better approaches for coping with misbehavior. mutually, some instructors do no longer have solid education, help from their principals, help from the dad and mom. also, misbehaving scholars can make any instructor loose his or her mood. Does your instructor act like this usually or become she merely having a foul day? Is someone contained in the kind a brat? I were given tried of coping with bratty youthful ones and were given out of the lecture room. possibly your instructor might want to, too!