is it fare for Ratan Tata to set up factory at Singur?

Question

isn't it against humanity or only the millionairs has
the right to live in country.what are the uses of his
several welfares running in the country or abroad.
please note that whenever crime against humanity will
rise my voice will be much louder and louder.one should never forget the caste of mankind.

Answer 1

OUR COUNTRY IS RUN BY TA TA RELIANCE AND OTHER BIG SHOOT. THEY ARE HAVING LIBERTY TO WORK AT ANY PLACE. FOR THEM OUR GOVERNMENT CAN BREAK HOUSE AND CLOSE THE SMALL BUSINESS TO HELP THEM TO RUN THEIR BUSINESS WITHOUT COMPETITION. SHORTLY ALL THE HARYANA'S AGRICULTURE LAND WILL BE PURCHASED BY RELIANCE.

Answer 2

Dear Kundu Singh,

It is of course not fair at all for the Tata's to set up a unit at Singur. Tata's themselves have a lot of lands, estates & plenty of places to start a car unit. But, in West Bengal, they have decided to start a small car project, only because, the land cost is very cheap, the labour is very cheap & the State Governement is giving all support to the Tata's & what else do you need. Mr.Ratan Tata will of course give a cheap car & take all the credit.
Don't you know that our country India, only belongs to the rich & powerful. Who really cares for the poor farmers?
These Tata's, Birla's, Ambani's, Mittal's, Bajaj's, etc. etc. are the only priveleged citizens of our country, the rest are all useless.
Our politicians also have to support these rich industrialists, as their own vested interests are taken care.
All our industrialists & politicians, put together, are probably richer than the rest of the population.
There are millions & millions of people who would agree with you & me, but, who cares?

Answer 3

You cannot deny the fact that industrialisation is necessary for rapid development in the country. At the same time, certain safeguards are necessary for those whose land were taken over by the government. They need to be assured of an employment and adequate compensation should be given to them. Wherever possible, only such land which are fallow and not cultivable need be used for industries.

Answer 4

Have you heard a place called Tatanagar. Tata acquired land, similar issues rose for the acquisition. But if you look at tatanagar today, the living standards of the people over there have improved. tata not inly developped the industry over there but they also emphasized in development of the community over there.

Tata Motors has selected a group of 11 trainees from Singur villages for 6-months training, according to a press release from the company.

The 11 trainees, all of whom have in the past attended Government-run Industrial Training Institute courses, have been selected out of the 21 candidates who responded to Tata Motors' initiative and appeared for a written test and interview held on December 25, 2006, at Singur.
http://www.blonnet.com/2007/01/05/stories/2007010502371100.htm

Tata Motors on February 10, 2007 organised a written test and interview for the second batch of Industrial Training Institute (ITI) educated youth from the Singur area, who had earlier registered with the West Bengal Industrial Development Corporation (WBIDC). Fifteen candidates appeared for the tests. Those who qualify and meet the necessary criteria will be provided with an extensive six-month training by the company.

This initiative by Tata Motors for ITI-trained Singur youth was started on December 25, 2006, when the first such batch of 21 candidates appeared for tests. From that batch, Tata Motors has already selected 11 candidates, whose training at a company facility is being finalised. During the six-month period, Tata Motors will provide the trainees with hostel facilities, and also pay a monthly stipend.
http://www.tata.com/tata_motors/releases/20070212_1.htm

by Tata Motors and the West Bengal Industrial Development Corporation (WBIDC) today to get training from the corporate house. The candidates included residents of Singur who had earlier undergone a technical course at Ramakrishna Mission Shilpamnadira in Belur. The course was organised by the WBIDC. The batch also included candidates who had not earlier qualified in previous tests held for the Industrial Training Institute (ITI)-trained candidates on December 25 last year and February 10 this year. As per WBIDC and the company's plan, candidates clearing the test would be eligible for advanced training by Tata to enhance their job-attaining capacity. According to information, 15 ITI-trained candidates who earlier cleared the previous rounds of written examinations and interviews would get a six-month training at Tata Motors' Jamshedpur facility. Slated to leave for Jamshedpur on February 28, the candidates are scheduled to begin their training programme from March 1. Post-training, they would be eligible for employment in the company's proposed small car factory in Singur, officials said. "All 179 candidates enlisted with us have appeared for the examination, including those who have also been trained by ITI," Tarasankar Mitra, project officer at Ramakrishna Mission Shilpa Mandira said. "Most candidates are satisfied with their performance."
http://in.news.yahoo.com/070226/48/6cj2t.html

All we need to do is keep monitoring the project. We cannot just jsut assume as to what is fair and waht is not unless we have the complete idea about the project.

As far as politcal parties that are opposing the project are concerned, they don't care if their supporters set fire to vehicles, block trains, beat up police. Don't these acts have any ill effect on the society? All they care about is that Tata is wrong...

:-)