Toy Soldiers - Martika v eminem, mad world Tears for fears v gary Jules......?

Question

which is better of these 5 cover versions A or B



1 Toy Soldiers A Martika or B Eminem
2) Mad World A Tears for Fears or B Gary Jules
3) Edge of 17 A Stevie Nicks or B Lindsey Lohan
4) Cats in the Cradle A Cat Stevens or B Ugly Kid Joe
5) Ms Jackson A Outkast or B The Vines


I'll tell you which I like better of each one later on. whoevers 5 is nearest to mine gets the points

After 11 answers, no one has the same as me, although someone has 4

Answer 1

1 B
2 A
3 A
4 B
5 A

Answer 2

1. Markita - I don't like rap over a real song
2. Gary Jules - just because of Donnie Darko
3. Stevie Nicks - NO ONE can match Stevie's voice
4. Cat Stevens - much more subtle and effective than UKJ
5. Outkast - its funnier, "ooh, I am FOR REAL!!"

Answer 3

1) A .... 2) B .... 3) A .... 4) B .... 5) B

Answer 4

1/Eminem
2/Gary Jules
3/Stevie Nicks
4/Cat Stevens ( i don't know Ugly Kid )
5/Outkast

Edit...I think yours are b,b,b,b,a

Answer 5

a
a
b
a
a

i like eminem, and i don't like lindsay lohan, but i can clearly tell which always "sounds" better. which is "done" better by the artist would have to go...

b
b
a
b
a

Answer 6

EMINEM / TEARS FOR FEARS / STEVIE NICKS / UGLY KID JOE / OUTKAST

Answer 7

cats in the cradle is not by cat stevens, it is by harry chapin

Answer 8

1A
2B
3A
4B
5A

Obviously Julie and I aren't going to be friends... :-)

Answer 9

a
a
a
b
a

Answer 10

b
a
b
a
b