Can you please tell me if you think the following bands are punk, emo, or neither? Thanks!
1.American Hi-Fi
2.My Chemical Romace
3.Panic! At The Disco
4.Gob
5.Goldfinger
6.Blink 182
7.Cartel
8.The Descendents
9.Fall Out Boy
10.Sex Pistols
11.AFI
12.Green Day
13.Jet
14.New Order
15.Rise Against
16.Rock n' Roll Soldiers
17.Something Corporate
18.Smash Mouth
19.Sum 41
20.Angels and Airwaves
21.Plus 44
22.Weezer
23.Yellowcard
24.ACDC
25.Aerosmith
26.Bon Jovi
27.Prince
28.Rolling Stones
29.Red Hot Chili peppers
30.Unwritten Law
31.311
I know it's a lot and that some of them aren't familiar, but please, try your best. Thanks. ^_^
2007-02-26 07:40:54 · 16 answers · asked by King Kee 3 in Entertainment & Music ➔ Music
*Romance. Typo there. Sorry.
2007-02-26 07:42:37 · update #1
individually, by the way
2007-02-26 07:44:50 · update #2
Yes. Bella Mars said it.
Real emo is pretty much dead now. If you think AFI, Panic etc are emo then you've been fooled. Many bands these days are INCORRECTLY labelled as emo when they are not.
If you want to know about real emo, then go back to the DC bands that spawned the genre.
BTW, AFI= Punk. They've been around longer than most people think. They are not new. They formed a more than a decade and a half ago. They used to be a very respected underground hardcore/punk band back in the days. EBHC!
They have released more than 24 albums and EP's combined. Most of that is Punk. They are not emo. You don't hear true emo music anymore.
I'm not into lumping bands and labelling them but......
Sex Pistols, The Descendents and old-school AFI= Punk
Prince, The Rollingstones, New Order, AC/DC= Legends
Panic! much like Nickelback= Unchanging.
Angels And Airwaves= Rot in hell
2007-02-27 18:16:02 · answer #1 · answered by Anonymous · 2⤊ 0⤋
1.American Hi-Fi emo
2.My Chemical Romace emo
3.Panic! At The Disco emo
4.Gob
5.Goldfinger punk
6.Blink 182 punk
7.Cartel
8.The Descendents punk
9.Fall Out Boy emo
10.Sex Pistols punk
11.AFI punk
12.Green Day punk
13.Jet neither
14.New Order
15.Rise Against punk
16.Rock n' Roll Soldiers
17.Something Corporate
18.Smash Mouth neither
19.Sum 41 neither
20.Angels and Airwaves neither
21.Plus 44
22.Weezer neither
23.Yellowcard emo
24.ACDC ROCK
25.Aerosmith ROCK
26.Bon Jovi ROCK
27.Prince ROCK
28.Rolling Stones ROCK
29.Red Hot Chili peppers ROCK
30.Unwritten Law neither
31.311 neither
hope it helps.
just curious...why were u asking??
2007-02-26 16:28:16 · answer #2 · answered by deviantmynd 2 · 1⤊ 1⤋
1.American Hi-Fi-pop punk
2.My Chemical Romace-scremoish
3.Panic! At The Disco-Pop/Punk/dance
4.Gob-punk
5.Goldfinger-ska
6.Blink 182-pop punk
7.Cartel-pop punk
8.The Descendents-punk
9.Fall Out Boy-pop punk
10.Sex Pistols-old school punk
11.AFI-punk
12.Green Day-pop/punk
13.Jet-pop/rock
14.New Order-synth/poprock
15.Rise Against-scremo-ish
16.Rock n' Roll Soldiers-indie rock
17.Something Corporate-piano rock
18.Smash Mouth-neither
19.Sum 41-pop/punk
20.Angels and Airwaves-pop/punk
21.Plus 44-pop/punk
22.Weezer-alterative/emo
23.Yellowcard-pop/punk
24.ACDC-rock
25.Aerosmith-rock
26.Bon Jovi-lol
27.Prince-neither
28.Rolling Stones-rock
29.Red Hot Chili peppers-rock
30.Unwritten Law-pop/punk
31.311-hard band to categorize
2007-02-26 18:12:24 · answer #3 · answered by Anonymous · 3⤊ 0⤋
iim like 15 so ye.
1.American Hi-Fi - neither
2.My Chemical Romace - EMO. used to be ok but now.
3.Panic! At The Disco - EMO. but more electronica
4.Gob - neither
5.Goldfinger - dunno.
6.Blink 182 - punkish.. but more rock if you get me.
7.Cartel - dunno.
8.The Descendents - punk
9.Fall Out Boy - urm.. emoish.
10.Sex Pistols - punk
11.AFI - dunno
12.Green Day - want to be punk but neither
13.Jet - neither
14.New Order - neither
15.Rise Against - punk
16.Rock n' Roll Soldiers - punk
17.Something Corporate - punk
18.Smash Mouth - dunno
19.Sum 41 - urm.. rock
20.Angels and Airwaves - like blink182 (same singer) rockish.
21.Plus 44 - rock supose.
22.Weezer - punk.
23.Yellowcard - dunno
24.ACDC - punk
25.Aerosmith - neither
26.Bon Jovi - dunno
27.Prince - neither
28.Rolling Stones - punk/rock
29.Red Hot Chili peppers - rock.
30.Unwritten Law - neither
31.311 - dunno
2007-02-26 16:13:27 · answer #4 · answered by rosey_pie_ox 1 · 0⤊ 2⤋
Punk- The Sex Pistols, The Descendents, Greenday, A.F.I
AFI's first 3 albums were just pure quality hardcore punk.
AFI ain't emo. Don't talk sh/t if you've only heard Miss Murder or LLW, because you know nothing. Emo died years ago.
Greenday, some may disagree, but they did play punk back in the days.
2007-02-28 02:56:12 · answer #5 · answered by EBHC 2 · 2⤊ 0⤋
1.American Hi-Fi- heh, they are closer to emo, but not really either
2.My Chemical Romace-emo punk (hey emo came from punk)
3.Panic! At The Disco-fast, blingy emo
4.Gob-dunno who this is
5.Goldfinger-I think I know who this is. sort of punk
6.Blink 182-pop-punk
7.Cartel-dunno
8.The Descendents-okay, there is not an ounce of emo here. Punk!
9.Fall Out Boy-emo
10.Sex Pistols-again with the not an ounce of emo. Punk
11.AFI-emo
12.Green Day-green day is still punk. A bit poppier each album but still punk.
13.Jet-neither
14.New Order-punk
15.Rise Against-punk
16.Rock n' Roll Soldiers-dunno
17.Something Corporate-emo
18.Smash Mouth-oh god, neither
19.Sum 41-poppy punk
20.Angels and Airwaves-they probably wouldn't call themselves emo but they sure as hell ain't punk
21.Plus 44-dunno
22.Weezer-neither
23.Yellowcard-pop-punk at it's god-awful worse
24.ACDC-neither
25.Aerosmith-neither
26.Bon Jovi-can I just laugh? neither
27.Prince-HAAAAAAA neither
28.Rolling Stones-neither
29.Red Hot Chili peppers-neither
30.Unwritten Law-punk
31.311-They'e actually pop-SKA-punk They can be okay
2007-02-26 15:49:56 · answer #6 · answered by T 4 · 0⤊ 3⤋
1.American Hi-Fi-?
2.My Chemical Romace- pop punk
3.Panic! At The Disco-scene
4.Gob-?
5.Goldfinger-?
6.Blink 182-pop punk
7.Cartel-pop punk
8.The Descendents-?
9.Fall Out Boy-pop punk
10.Sex Pistols-punk
11.AFI-screamo
12.Green Day-rock
13.Jet-pop punk
14.New Order-pop punk
15.Rise Against-pop punk
16.Rock n' Roll Soldiers-?
17.Something Corporate-?
18.Smash Mouth-pop
19.Sum 41-pop punk
20.Angels and Airwaves-scene
21.Plus 44-scene
22.Weezer-rock
23.Yellowcard-pop punk
24.ACDC-classic rock
25.Aerosmith-classic rock
26.Bon Jovi-classic rock
27.Prince-?
28.Rolling Stones-punk
29.Red Hot Chili peppers-old stuff-grunge new-punk
30.Unwritten Law-emo
31.311-?
2007-02-26 15:48:08 · answer #7 · answered by conversegirl 1 · 0⤊ 3⤋
There is nothing pop about AFI. or screamo.They've been around almost 16 years, and were once a harcore punk band. Listen to their first 2 albums....there's nothing "pop" about them. There's more to them than Miss Murder and Love Like Winter.
None of these bands are emo...emo isn't short for emotional its short for emotive hardcore, and then later emocore. Real emo ahs died out in the 90s. you will never catch it on the radio.
3,6,7,9,19 I would consider pop-rock.
2007-02-26 16:24:26 · answer #8 · answered by BellaMars 4 · 1⤊ 1⤋
mmm i don't much bother with labelling music because i think you should just enjoy it, but i will try and put these artists into labels:
1. don't know.
2. neither with a slight bit of both
3. neither
4.
5. sort of punk
6. pop punk
7.
8.
9. a little of both with some pop
10. punk
11. a little of both, more punk
12. soft punk pop
13. neither-they're rock
14. new wave
15. punk
16.
17.
18. neither-pop rock
19. punk pop
20. a little of both
21. a little of both
22. neither
23. neither
24.NEITHER
25.NEITHER
26. NEITHER
27. NEITHER
28. NEITHER
29. eh they've got some punk in em. it's mostly funk rock.
30
31. neither...
2007-02-28 23:12:19 · answer #9 · answered by Tina 5 · 0⤊ 0⤋
The "simple plan fan" guy is a moron, Simple Plan are FAR from Punk, they are another crappy emo/pop band. The only Punk bands on your list are The Descendents and Sex Pistols.
2007-02-26 15:49:02 · answer #10 · answered by iamblizzy 4 · 2⤊ 1⤋