PLEASE rate my fantasy baseball team 1-100, 1= terrible, 100=fantastic, i really need your opinion, please?

Question

this is my team

c- jorge posada

1b- micheal cuddyer

2b- brandon phillips

3b- aramis ramirez

ss- jose reyes

of- jason bay

of- grady sizemore

of- adam dunn

of- delmon young

util- joe crede

util- jim edmonds

bench- nick jhonson

bench- brandon inge

sp- jeremy bonderman

sp- justin verlander

rp- joe namath

rp- billy wagner

p- jj puntz

p- chein- ming wang

p- josh johnson

bench- bartolo colon

bench- tim hudson

bench- mark mulder

please tell me ur opinion, should i trade any player that are busts (witch ones). should i trade for another great pitcher? If so witch one?

Answer 1

...not bad for ur position players, ur pitching isnt that bad, just the tim hudson and mark mulder picks..colon was probably a steal, and hopefully he can do something this year, but to rely on the sophomore years of verlander and bonderman is a risk..they had some good years last year..now that i look at ur team its not that bad, u have variety, but your lacking probably in batting avg. and possibly homers..still not a bad team..

Answer 2

78...C and 1B is a little weak but other than that you have a solid overall offense. Zambrano is a lights out pitcher and will get more wins with the Cubs this year. Same for Kazmir because he is an amazing young talent. Rivera and Cordero are solid closers that will get you at least 30 saves, 60 K's...Smoltz and Weaver had great years last year and Weaver should be even better playing a full year. Your bench for pitching is really good. I would consider starting Hamels over Smoltz or Fuentes over Cordero. Secondly, I would do that trade because Holliday can get any stats and is on a better team and has a better average. Lastly, I wouldnt go for Howard because that manager is going to want a lot for him and that will just disrupt the balance of your team.

Answer 3

60
You have 2 football players? Namath and a guy who Puntz...
Get rid of Joe Namath, QB's won't help you. Trade him for Joe Nathan, he is a much better closer. Instead of kicking on 4th down you should go with closer - Putz...
Cudd boy and Dunn can't top .270 Avg. Cudd is a liability and your backup Nick Johnson has a broken leg.
Check the waiver wire, you don't have much to trade without crippling another position. you are leading in the closer category but trading a close would comprise that. You may be able to move Wagner for Sheffield or Helton then lose Crede or Inge for Zumaya or Rafael Soriano.
Hopefully you are in a 4x4 or 5x5 roto league, if you are in a head 2 head, you're dead. And I hope your league doesn't count K's against the hitters.

Answer 4

I'd give you a 75 overall. You obviously went early and hard for RP and they are really good (just so you know, it is Joe Nathan, Joe Namath was a quarter back for the Jets and briefly for the Rams). I like most of your pitchers but none of the guys on the bench. Check to see if Chuck James is available. He has a lot of potential and I think he is being overlooked sometimes this year. Unless you really want 3 top RP I'd probably trade one of them with one of your pitchers for a top pitcher who you will get more wins and strikeouts from.

I think that offense wins fantasy baseball. I find it easier to find pitchers on waivers throughout the year. Your lineup is alright but I would try and get a better first baseman. I would try and package Cuddyer and Dunn for one of the top tier 1B with a better average. Then again, Cuddyer might have another good year, but I just don't like Dunn because he's an AVG killer and you can find OF throughout the year on waivers. Nick Johnson has a broken leg and probably won't play until at least mid season so get rid of him. Edmonds seems past his prime but it won't hurt to see how he does. Good luck with your team this year. I like the speed you have in your lineup, but you need a little more power.

Answer 5

90. You have a really good outfield, and Jose Reyes will single handedly win you the stolen base category numerous times. There are some questions about your starting pitching but there will be some sleepers to pick up from the free agents if you need. Also you have 3 great closers. Good Team.

Answer 6

Well. your infield is not the best on the left side with Cuddyer and Phillips, now Jose, and Aramis they are great. Posada is an okay catcher and he will get you points. Utility is okay with Edmonds, and you have the right people benched. You have some good starters and your relief is also great. I would say get rid of Hudson, Mulder, and Johnson, but only if you get something good out of it. Personally I wouldn't want Edmonds or Nick Johnson because of their injury history.

Answer 7

I like your team overall, especially since you can slot cuddyer into 1B (I love his potential and the value you probably got on him). Mark Mulder is injured so keep an eye on him, and I might consider moving bartolo colon just because he has a lot of question marks. Adam Dunn is an average killer so you might want to think about moving him as well for someone who might not hit for quite as much power, but hits for a higher average.

Answer 8

45! It looks like you went early on pitching & outfield. I would have held off on the pitching a bit and picked up a few more hitters. pitchers are always getting hurt but hitters tend to hold up better.... that said Its a preety good team, not great but you should break 500

Answer 9

I really like your team, i'm jealous, my draft os tomorrow so hopefully i can get good pitching like you did. Offense is good also. I'll give it a 92 out of 100. Watch out for Mulder though he might struggle early on until he figures out what he's doing after coming of an injury.

Answer 10

You need to start edmonds and Inge. Also, maybe think about starting Hudson over bonderman. Wang is garbage too, and this is supported by his low strikeout total last year.You need to trade him while his stock is high and people still think he is a number one starter. The way it is, i would give it a 70.