why did the germans never carry out commando attacks on mainland britain, like we did on occupied europe?

Answer 1

The Germans were never big into "commando" operations to the same degree as the British. The Germans did have a commando organization the "Brandenburgers" but the majority of their operations were performed in support of Army operations, i.e capturing or blowing up bridges behind enemy lines and so forth. Nor did they see much value in harassment operations.

The SS had their own commando organization "SS-Jagdverband" but again they mostly supported army tactical operations. Under Skorzeny they planned a great many deep behind enemy lines operations but most never made it past the drawing room for one reason or another.
The real problem is Germany lacked a visionary with the power and prestige of Churchill who was a proponent of commando operations.

Answer 2

There is one big assumption in this question and that is that there were no German commando raids on the UK during WWII.

Was there a German commando raid on the low level radar station at St. Lawrence in 1942? Reports from German sources indicate that shortly after the Bruneval Raid of February 1942, the German army also staged their own version of this raid on the Island.
The Bruneval raid was aimed at captuing German radar technology in a small-scale lightening commando raid. It was a complete success. British raids into enemy territory, both seaborne and aerial, are well documented, especially the RAF's role in supporting the French resistance. Until now, it was assumed the dreaded German raids, often caricatured as parachutists disguised as nuns, had never materialised. However, new information suggests that small scale commando raids by the Germans did take place at times along the South Coast.

One such raid is said to have occurred at St. Lawrence in an exact copy of the Bruneval raid several months after. A German commando unit was landed from a fast gunboat at St. Lawrence and, having scaled the cliff, were involved in a short fire fight with guards at the Radar station. It seems that a few British were killed in the fight. The German unit returned to a waiting U-boat, before crossing back acros the Channel.

Answer 3

Well, for one thing, they wouldn't have been able to work with local resistance fighters in the way that the Allies did in Europe.
What would have been achieved by commando raids on Britain? Very little I suspect, for great cost to the Germans. The Royal Navy still controlled the Channel which would have made crossings a hazardous affair.
The Allied Commando raids aims were disruption of the German war machine with the ultimate goal being the invasion of Europe. Where as the German invasion of Britain was never really a practical reality, for various reasons, one of which was that Hitler had his eyes on Russia. Which, as Napolean could have told him, was a mistake on his part.

Answer 4

Up to 1942 it was clear tht England was loosing the war against Germany.

Meanwhile to keep moral high, and slowly weaken the German war nachine England hit back whenever posible and gave Germany at least a bloody nose, recoiling herself for the future jaw breaking punch.

It was all England could do untill it was possible for her to give a full force defeat on a German army.

This oportunity presented itself on november 1942 when General Montgomery defeated Rommel´s , and von Thomma´s army in El Alamein north africa.

From then on thing began to get better for England and the free world and gloomier for the Axis.

It was the begining of the end for Germany´s dreams of world power.

On the other side Germany did not operate commando raids because they were very confident, as all their victories had been fast as thunderbolts, therefore they thought they did not need commando operations.

I belive the only commando operation the Germans led, was after D-Day when english speaking germans, dressed as american Rangers, behind American lines, they tries to confuse and disrupt the yankee effort.

Answer 5

Main reason every body has conquering Britain - WEATHER.
Often Hitler would plan invasion but bad weather interferred. Fog, rain, cold, storm, you name it Britain has terrible weather and the English Channel is hard to cross going North.
Also quite correctly one answer mentions Russia. In the 1950's we conveniently forgot what the Russians did to help the world beat Hitler.
Hitler made the mistake other fighters such as Napolean did and tried to conquer the Russian people. These great people burned their farms so that Hitler's troops would have no food. The Russians straved as well but they did to help defeat facism. In Leningrad in northern Russia they ran out of food while under siege from the facists. First the people ate rats, then leather, then their dead families, then nothing - rather than give in to Hitler's troops. When the German troops retreated Lenigrad people had only just survived. there were no grandparents, little children etc and they had to start again but they did it for the world. And now we have the nerve to call Leningrad St Petersburg.

Answer 6

One reason is the ability to retrieve the commando forces and return them home. this could be done easier by the British who basically could maintain naval superiority around the English and french coast. German commandos ran the risk of being "stuck" in England.

The Germans did have a few commando units, most notably the Brandenburgers, and Otto Skornzey's unit (which conducted the daring rescue of Mussulini from an alpine resort). however they were used in limited fashion to support major operations like capturing or destroying bridges, etc.

the Germans initially used paratroops (Eban Emmanuel, Crete) but after the horrific losses suffered by their airborne troops in Crete Hitler lost his taste for large scale airborne operations and the paratrooper units were used as standard infantry for the remainder of the war.

Answer 7

Because of their problems in the air battle ,that is the Battle of Britain, the Germans decided to focus their energies on Operation Barbarossa and North Africa with the invasions of Greece and Crete to give them necessary seaports. If you look at the history of Britain after 1066, there were not many successful invasions of the homeland and the Germans did not want a second front war and believed the Russians to be weak and sub-human and we must remember that affiliation and actually admiration of Britan at one time by Hitler.

Answer 8

the numerous issues dealing with the Germans became the Royal army, which may have destroyed Hitlers invasion barges and the RAF. without air superiority, Germany did no longer have a probability of landing troops and transferring them as brazenly as they'd like. If britain had in effortless words been separated by France by 15 miles of flat land, truly than the channel, then our naval power would were ineffective and our airfields would were over run. After the French campaign, the British military became in disary. regardless of if it managed to salvage its kit, its skill to co-ordinate a protection, given the time obtainable, would not were doable. also, the RAF became confusing pressed interior the conflict of england. If the Germans did no longer have flimsy barges to carry their troops, yet ought to pass their tanks and troops immediately, utilizing any air fields etc, on the chanell land mass... in short, we would were creamed. success

Answer 9

Because Commando attacks were a substitute for the real attacks Britain couldn't make.

Answer 10

One of the world's most beautiful cities is St. Petersburg; discover it with hotelbye . St. Petersburg has most of the components for an wonderful vacation experience: large art, lavish structure, crazy nightlife, an extraordinary record and rich national traditions which have influenced and nurtured a few of the contemporary world's best literature, audio, and aesthetic art. From the mysterious twilight of the White Nights to world-beating opera and ballet shows on wonderful winter nights, St. Petersburg charms and excites in every period so discover this particular town because it provides you with an remarkable vacation.