Who thinks Rudy got eliminated on American Idol cuz he didn't respect Simon?

Question

I really didn't like Rudy when he said he doesn't care what Simon has to say. I mean come on, Simon is the Judge! Simon has power about who stays and who goes. So for Rudy to say something like that was totally arrogant and stupid. I personally didn't care for his singing either. He sounded somewhat squeaky.

Answer 1

Hmmm...I think that if that were true then Chris Sligh would be gone too. Rudy was good, but not great, you know? honestly, i was surprised that Sanjaya wasn't eliminated. He and Antonella should have definitely been gone. Simon is the judge, but so are Randy and Paula, so i don't think he would be eliminated just for disrespecting Simon. Also, The judges weren't deciding who stays and who goes. America was.

Answer 2

Rudy will be elliminated because of his false judgements? Maybe he got nervous and ran out of words by that time...Performing in front of the judges (especially Simon), being struck in the spotlight, being seen by millions of people around the world...Of course any one would go speechless even professional artists forget their lines from time to time and say something they do really want but it turns the other way around. How is that for a beginner like Rudy? In the end, talent still counts and I agree with you that he's not that really good but he can sing though. GURLS ROCK HARD!! ^^

Answer 3

i totally agree. that was a really bad move for him. simon is a professional and rudy was just an okay singer. and most of america usually agrees with simon.

Answer 4

THE JUDGES DON'T HAVE A SAY IN WHO STAYS AND WHO GOES. IT IS UP TO THE PEOPLE WHO VOTE.I DO AGREE THAT WHAT RUDY SAID WAS IGNORANT.PERSONALLY I LIKE SIMON BECAUSE HE SPEAKS THE TRUTH.MOST PEOPLE WANT HIM TO SUGAR COAT THINGS

Answer 5

Simon sucks!

Answer 6

If that were true then Chris would be gone for the teletubby comment. He is gone because he is forgettable.