should jim rice be in the baseball hall of fame?

Question

next year might be his only chance ....just want peoples opinion ..thanks

Answer 1

Yes, Jim Rice is absolutely a hall of famer. Also Dwight Evans belongs in the hall as well.

Answer 2

Jim Rice should be a Hall of Famer in any year. I think it is a travesty and an insult to a man who had his game to be kept out. The man was one of the leading mashers in his day (70's & 80's) who was counted on year after year to be one of the homer and RBI leaders. He may have only hit 37 to 40 homers per year. He hit them clean and at a time when it was harder to hit them bombs.

How on earth they can keep guys like Jim Rice, Bert Blyleven, Andre Dawson, Jack Morris, Goose Gossage out and let someone like Bruce Sutter in who is NOT quite hall of fame material in is evidence that the BBWAA has taken a Kamikaze nose dive in the IQ department.

Answer 3

I think he was great for a few years, and was able to have an overall productive 15 years, but just as Dale Murphy, and Andre Dawson, the career totals are below the currect cut-off line for a hall-of-famer. But the hall, as most educated fans know, isn't all fair. Ryno, a great player, is in the hall, but Dawson isn't.

Answer 4

Yes, Jim Rice belongs in the hall of fame. I don't know why they don't vote him in.

Answer 5

Yes, he was the most feared hitter in baseball for over a decade and his career certainly earned him the honor of being in the Hall.

Answer 6

Yes. he was possibly the most feared hitter in the AL for 10+ seasons. i think dominance for a ten+ year period of time is more hall worthy than mediocrity over a 20-25 year period of time.

Answer 7

Curt Schilling - i love his possibilities, and there are worse already interior the hall of popularity (Drysdale) the bloody sock already is why no longer Curt in some unspecified time sooner or later. Jeff Bagwell - i imagine luggage has an reliable probability of in some unspecified time sooner or later being inducted yet honestly no longer a usual pollhall of popularity, huge and strong yet career decrease short. awesome totals notwithstanding for a fifteen year career. must be inducted jointly with his counterpart the different Killer B (Biggio) Jim Thome - Thome is a captivating case will end with more suitable than 600 residing house Runs and more suitable than 1500 RBI's yet a sub par Avg and Base Hits (2138) he will be there in some unspecified time sooner or later in simple terms what year which will be we would ought to attend a lengthy time period. Jim Edmonds - no longer genuine positive why he's in this record yet hall of very reliable in simple terms no longer hall of popularity Juan Gonzalez - Its nevertheless conceivable, i imagine this one relies upon on his involvement with steroids. awesome numbers for a career decrease short by injuries, in simple terms imagine what he would have performed if he performed 162 video games in line with year in his very last 3 seasons. Vladimir Guerrero - he's unquestionably on his way and arguably already has the numbers to pass in, If he remains healthful for yet another 3 or 4 season then it really is a no-brainer if no longer then we can all in simple terms ought to attend and observe. he's 34 and could be turning 35 in spring practise so we can in simple terms ought to attend and observe. Trevor Hoffman - they're going to ought to outline what a hall of popularity relief pitcher is earlier i am going to contact upon Mr Hoffman (or Mr Rivera for that count number) in additional suitable than one hundred seasons there are in effortless words 5 relief Aces inducted (hands, Gossage, Wilhelm, Sutter, Eckersley) Mike Mussina - Hmm thrilling one which .638 prevailing pct cant be left out that a million.192 WHIP cant be left out yet that 3.sixty 8 era is almost intense, there are way extra appropriate yet a lot worse already in, we would ought to make sure what them writers imagine of his contributions, rings and his friends. Gary Sheffield - I say if he reaches 3000 Base Hits then it really is a no-brainer if he would not then i do not comprehend, honestly on the bubble. Larry Walker - I continually popular Larry notwithstanding the in effortless words way he receives interior the hall of popularity is an similar way you or i am going to, purchase a cost ticket. reliable question Merry Christmas

Answer 8

no he shouldn't. he is borderline. numbers similar to dave parker and ellis burks, who arent in. i disagree with one of the responses above. he was not the most feared hitter for a decade. i would argue that reggie jackson and george brett were much more feared. jim also had limited post season success and as 0 rings. that being said, i wouldnt be upset if he were inducted

Answer 9

Ye he should. He was the heart and soul of the Red Sox in his day. His numbers aren't too bad either. He would get my vote.

Answer 10

Yes, he was a great hitter.