who would u say is over rated football defender in the English Premiership?

Question

for me its Rio Ferdinand in my vewe he is the David James as a defender

Answer 1

Titus Bramble - although probably not over rated - is the worst defender I have ever seen in the Prem.

Answer 2

Yeah £30 Rio Ferdinand is one of the laziest defenders in the game. He is meant to be the cool head in defence but at time he does not even care.

I'll also say that Wes Brown could be one the most under rated defenders in the premiership.

I don't support man utd but if you give Brown a few games so he can find his form, he becomes a very good players.

I think Man Utd should play Brown and Vidic in defence.

Answer 3

Pascal Cygan, Wayne Bridge, Rio, like you said, ash cole etc
I think Wayne Bridge is THE overrated because WHAT DOES HE DO??? I saw him on MOTD and he did a great cross, that being the only good thing he did the whole game, and they reckon hes a god! also, on trhe subject of ash cole, why pay 15-20 million for a left back? (if you include what you would have originally payed for Gallas.) Its annoying when you think that defenders dont win matches, strikers do.

Answer 4

Ashley Cole

Answer 5

Zat Knight of Fulham.

Answer 6

Ashley Cole should be singing, "Take a look at me now" Yes I agree with you Ferdinand is tosh....

Answer 7

I rushed to answer your Q only seeing the title and felt v smug as I wanted to be the first to put rio down, and darn, u got there first!!!

Yeah he is pants, closely followed by Babayaro at newcastle

Answer 8

Rio - always guaranteed for one howler per game. Any he never tackles (but much of this is due to a good reading of the game)

Answer 9

John Terry!

Answer 10

got to be anton ferdinand not rio.