is this a good fantsy basebal trade?

Question

i get cano and mussina and i give him webb....my second baseman is luis castillo ...and my other pitchers are arroyo bedard kazmir ishringhousen,todd jones and otsuka...

and this is my team Luis Castillo, Jermaine Dye, Prince Fielder, Alex Gordon, Ken Griffey, Travis Hafner, Jeremy Hermida, Ramon Hernandez, Jason Isringhausen, Todd Jones, Scott Kazmir, Justin Morneau, Akinori Otsuka, Hanley Ramirez, Alex Rodriguez, Scott Rolen, Taylor Tankersley, Brandon Webb, Delmon Young please rate it

Answer 1

I would not do it, you are getting an average pitcher and a just above average 2B when you have a decent 2B and a TOP level starter if you do not make the trade. I would see if I could package Rolen for something decent since you are pretty set at 3B with A-Rod...Prince Feilder may not be bad to shop as well.

Answer 2

Go for it. Webb will not get a lot of run support with the lineup that Arizona has. Unlike Mussina who could have a fair outing and still get the win due to great Yankee run support.

Answer 3

Sounds like a great trade. Yes you give up webb who is not that much better ( I think he is equal to Mussina ) Secondly you add a good 2ber. So you make a big winning on this trade.

Answer 4

id do it. mussina has proved himself he's a seasoned veteran. webb is not and he's not getting much support from the diamondbacks offense. cano is young but 2nd base is the hardest position to fill this year he's going to be in the top 5 for second basemen with his stats.

Answer 5

i would trade, cano is a reliable 2nd baseman, and webb was a fluke, but your pitching roation seems fine, but i'd try to get someone else besides mussina

Answer 6

the season hasnt even started yet why so early