Does a tree falling over in a forest make a noise if there is no receptor (human or animal ear) to hear it?

Question

Answer this question: Does a tree falling over in a forest make a noise if there is no receptor (human or animal ear) to hear it?
In your answer, describe why you think it does or does not. How could I test this? :) -ry

Answer 1

It depends on your definition of noise. If noise is the interpretation of the brain of soundwaves, then no. If noise is the soundwaves themselves, then yes.

Answer 2

Ok this is a reasonable question. Answer me this then, does a tree falling in the forest make noise if there is a receptor to hear it? If it does, then obviously it would make a noise even if there is no one to hear it. Its all the same, if you hear it or dont, it makes a noise. Conduct a survey, if a tree falls and you dont hear it, ask around and see if someone else does or record it (leave a microphone or something like that to test it out)

Answer 3

well a noise is sound waves that are caused by kinetic energy being transfered to the surrounding atmosphere. so yes there is a "noise". These sound waves do not necesarrily have to hit a membrane to be turned into an auditory anomally. You could test this by putting a microphone next to an object that you can make fall over from far enough away that you won't hear it but record the sound waves that contact the membrane in the microphone. It will tell you if this is true.

Answer 4

Don H and others confuse sound and listening to. Sound is basically the vibration. listening to the processing of that sound through a knowledge able to idea. We trust that sound exists even if we're not there to take heed to it because we develope merchandise permanence between the a at the same time as of 9 and three hundred and sixty 5 days previous. After that, we comprehend that issues we grow to be conscious of also take position when we are no longer round. medical consequences does no longer be smart if relied on human perceivers in some type of unnatural way. Many imagine quantum mechanics relies upon upon a perceiver. It does no longer. It relies upon upon interplay with complicated structures, no matter if those structures are human brains or no longer.

Answer 5

No. Noise is something that someone hears if there is no one around to hear the noise than the tree falling doesn't make a noise.

Answer 6

ha! i love this question. if the tree falls and there is no human nor animal to hear the noise then it never made a noise. you see noise is is caused by a sound wave that interacts with our eardrum. so if a soundwave is created and there is no eardrum to recieve it, then there is no noise! the tree produced a soundwave that never became a noise

Answer 7

I think that it does still make a noise even if noone is around to hear it. What does it fall silently just because no one is around

Answer 8

Of course it does. Trees need air to live. Air carries sound waves regardless if anyone is there to hear it. Don't pay any attention to libtards. They're still trying to decide what "is" is.
And no, global warming doesn't make trees fall. It's just another figment of paranoid liberal minds.

Answer 9

of course it makes noise. it has to. that is the energy given off when the tree hits the ground. i don't really think you can test it, unless you record it. but then youd have to use a deaf person to knock the tree down.

Answer 10

Of course it does! If it doesn't, then how does a tree "know" to make a noise when somebody IS around?

Answer 11

No...sound is only meaningful if someone/thing (including microphones/recorders) detects it. Otherwise, there are just vibrations.

It's a little subtle. For those who gave me a thumb's down, I suggest you consider what sound is. Sound is a reaction in your brain to vibratory stimuli. Sound and the vibrations that cause them are not the same thing.

Technically, the vibrations are the same regardless if there are observers, but sound requires an observer. If you asked if there were still vibrations capable of inducing a sensation of noise, then I would say yes.