Why are scottish MPs undemocratcially allowed to vote on English Only Issues?

Question

I think it is disgraceful how foreign MPs from Wales, NI and Scotland can decide what happens in our country and yet we can do bugger all about theirs. Foreign MPs should be barred from votes that affect only England. It is an insult to so-called democracy, although it isn't surprising considering most of the useless Labour cabinet isn't English anyway

Answer 1

Scottish MPs, along with Welsh MPs, as members of the House of Commons, may vote on any issue. The House of Commons is not an 'English Parliament', it forms the lower chamber or house of the UK parliament, established in the Palace of Westminster - The British Parliament.

I take your point very seriously indeed and so too does the government and the official opposition, the Tories. David Cameron is already looking at ways in which English issues should be debated and voted upon by English MPs - as is currently the case with Scottish and Welsh issues, where only MPs from either Scotland or Wales are allowed to vote.

Lets look at this carefully. An MP of an English constituency, may not in fact actually be 'English' by race. There are quite a few Welsh, Scottish and indeed Irish MPs who are elected as MP for an English constituency.

If none of the above suits the English, the answer to the problem may simply be to creat an English Assmbly or Parliament which is separate from Westminster, as is the Scottish Parliament and the Welsh Assembly, plus when they get their act together, the Northern Ireland Assembly at Storemont.

Answer 2

No, that is not any longer a honest or democratic equipment, yet considering at the same time as has that been some thing Westminster has ever had? there have been no moaning voices from England at the same time as the Conservatives were in potential with decrease than fifteen MP's in Scotland, so what gave the English majority of MP's then any actual to vote on Scottish subject matters? Oh, because we are an similar u . s . in accordance to Parliament. The Scots (be conscious the spelling, Angel) have administration of steerage and as such are completely entitled to repeal college costs. Why are you blaming Scots for vote casting hostile to an similar in England? you need to be blaming Labour as a rule, because that is Labour that are refusing it. the in trouble-free terms reason they did not cope with to derail it in Scotland is because the different activities quite loved the idea and Labour couldn't muster a majority. through the way, the West Lothian question is so suggested as because it grow to be raised as a controversy through the MP for that area, Tam Dalyell. humorous, isn't it, that it took a Scotsman to enhance the problem in Parliament in the first position? And he's a Labour guy. And in case you do not want Scottish MP's sitting at Westminster, tell your MP to push for a referendum on Scottish independence, because it is the in trouble-free terms way you receives rid people. Your serve, i trust. Edit - Bob Abuse... certain, it grow to be a Scottish king, James the sixth that united the Crowns. He grow to be no longer responsible for the Act of Union, which grow to be a 'tremendous' theory proposed through London and which may not in any respect have got here about if London hadn't given bribes to dissimilar contributors of the Scottish Parliament to vote for it. In immediately's money, the bribes provided amounted to correctly over 3 million pounds. So that is an English aspect, this Union. It honestly had, on the starting up, more beneficial advantages for England than Scotland. Did you at the moment that Scotland, which had no nationwide debt, took on a percentage of england's debt? And that it grow to be deemed that would want to there be a spread of a sparkling monarch what England agreed would bypass? that is why a lot money grow to be spent on bribes, and why the former Scottish Parliament are often suggested as a parcel of rogues. if that that they had done that in the well-known international, that that they had were dragged out through the inhabitants and shot. because they bought this u . s . to England, and the country were given no longer some thing out of the deal.

Answer 3

It's because most of the MPs representing Scottish constituencies are Labour and if Blair didn't have their support he would not be in power

Answer 4

It is because Labour never thought through the changes they made in the creation of the Scottish Parliament.