Make 2 teams of Lefties vs Righties, and pick who u think would have the edge and win a best of 7 series?

Question

Line-up
Lefties - Righties
C-
1B-
2B-
3B-
SS-
LF-
CF-
RF-

Pitching Staff-
Lefties - Righties
Rotation
1)
2)
3)
4)
5)

Bullpen
SU
SU
CL

Answer 1

Line-Up
C- Joe Mauer-Pudge Rodriguez
1B- Ryan Howard-Albert Pujols
2B- Chase Utley-Alfonso Soriano
3B- Eric Chavez-Alex Rodriguez
SS- Rafael Furcal-Miguel Tejada
LF- Scott Podsednik-Manny Ramirez
CF- Johnny Damon-Andruw Jones
RF- Ichiro Suzuki-Vladimir Guerrero
DH- David Ortiz-Mark Teixeira

Starting Pitchers
1) Johan Santana-Roy Halladay
2) Barry Zito-Roy Oswalt
3) Dontrelle Willis-Brandon Webb
4) Mark Buehrle-Chris Carpenter
5) Randy Johnson-Justin Verlander

Bullpen
SU- Scott Schowenweiss-Joel Zumaya
SU- Steve Kline-Kyle Farnsworth
CL- Billy Wagner-Mariano Rivera

Righties would win in 6

Answer 2

Lefties/ Righties
c - Joe Mauer/ Pudge Rodriguez
1b - Ryan Howard (or David Ortiz)/ Albert Pujols
2b - Chase Utley/ Robinson Cano
3b - Eric Chavez/ Alex Rodriguez
ss - Jose Reyes/ Miguel Tejada
lf - Barry Bonds/ Miguel Cabrera
cf - Grady Sizemore/ Carlos Beltran
rf - Ichiro/ Jermaine Dye

starting pitchers
lefties/ righties
Johan Santana/ Roy Halladay
Dontrelle Willis/ Chris Carpenter
Chris Capuano/ Brandon Webb
Barry Zito/ Carlos Zambrano
C.C. Sabathia/ Roy Oswalt

Bullpen
lefties/ righties
su - Trever Miller/ Scott Linebrink
su - Dennys Reyes/ Joel Zumaya
cl - Billy Wagner/ Mariano Rivera

I kind of cheated and stuck a few switch hitters on my list, and my team is entirely based on offensive statistics. It seems to mee that the righties have a slight edge in pitching depth while I would give it to the lefties on offense. It would probably go down to the 9th inning of game 7, and I'll take Rivera every time in that situation, so I would give it to the righties, even though I think the lefties have a slightly better team overall.