Ok. I have just joined so i do not know about anything that yall have talked about.. but i just got a thought...
ok. we all know that in GOF LV gave Pettigrew the silver hand.. I think he gave it to him because he u know brought LV back to life and all right.. if not then please someone tell me.. but does anyone know what the use of having the silver hand is for... could it have possibly been a horcrux?
What does it do what can it do..
u know the whole saying u stick a wooden stake through a vampires heart thats the only way that u can kill it.. and then the other saying saying u have to stick silver through a werewolf and thats the only way to kill it.. well could the reason for him giving it to pettigrew be to get rid of Lupin?
also.. does anyone else agree that D n S aren't dead.. i know Rowling has said that yes he really is dead... and i know that just like myself most people do not believe that dumbledore would do something like this but... outta just plain curiosity could he have created a horcrux... and there is nothing in the book about S being dead.. like no one from the ministry reported OMG he's dead or n e thing.. or am i 4getting.
my biggest wonder about dumbledores death my biggest wonder.. is.... He LOVED harry right i mean he really did and he made sure that no one got harry... could the same thing that lily did to save harry have happened with d n h only in a different way... i have so many questions...
o and where is fawks and is he and the invisibility cloak a horcrux.... then the 2 way mirror thing with S how do we know that he isn't being held captive or something............ GRRRRRRRRRRRRR
2007-02-11 15:37:46 · 2 answers · asked by lilmizmoodswings 1 in Arts & Humanities ➔ Books & Authors
Wow..you have a lot of theories.
First of all, there is only a slight chance that the silver hand is a horcrux, at least for me. I think that it was granted as a reward for Wormtail, who cut off his own hand to resurrect LV. But who knows, it might be of further use in the 7th book.
And though I would love to think that Dumbledore and Sirius aren't dead, I'm pretty sure they are. After all, the author herself told us so. Besides, there was some mention in OotP that Sirius really was dead, I just forgot where. And Dumbledore had his funeral, right?
Lastly, I have no idea where you got the idea of Fawkes and the cloak being Horcruxes. In the first place, LV wanted "trophies" didn't he? Something that, though not obvious, would be a sign of his power. And those two just aren't it. But as long as the book hasn't been released yet, we'll never know for sure.
If you want to read more rumors, why don't you try this link: http://forums.fictionalley.org/park/forumdisplay.php?s=&forumid=202
2007-02-11 18:59:09 · answer #1 · answered by squish 2 · 0⤊ 0⤋
yeh i think theyare horuxes
2007-02-11 17:42:05 · answer #2 · answered by Anonymous · 0⤊ 1⤋