Who is better Tom Brady or Peyton Manning?

Answer 1

Manning, he calls his own plays, better arm plays in a tougher division

Answer 2

Peyton Manning no doubt about it..Tom Brady only won 3 rings because he had the full package, great offense and great defense..how many records has he set..or is on his way to set..Peyton Manning barely has offensive line protection..yet he finds a way to get the ball to Reggie Wayne or Marvin Harrison, yet Peyton Manning ends up with a record 40 passing touchdowns, oh might i add Peyton Manning is a super bowl MVP, he carried his team to the Super Bowl and won it for them, i dont think there is a better player who has worn an NFL jersey then Peyton Manning

Answer 3

If you are talking about a better winner, it is obviuosly Tom Brady because he has three rings to prove it and Peyton has one now. But if you are talking statistics Peyton Manning has him. Tom Brady has only thrown for 4,000 yards once in his career while peyton has thrown for over 4,000 yards 7 times. Tom Brady has never thrown 30 TDs in a single season. Peyton Manning has thrown 30 TDs in 3 seasons including a record 49 TDs. Tom Brady has thrown over ten INTs in every season he has played, while Peyton Manning the last four years has thrown 10,10,10, and 9. For people who really watch football only throwing ten INTs in a season is amazing let alone 4 straight years. Also, Tom Brady has never had a 100.0 QB Rating. Peyton Manning has had a QB Rating over 100.0 the last three years: 121.1, 104.1, and this year 101.0. Tom Brady's highest QB rating is 92.6. Lastly, Brady has never completed 65% of his passes in a season while Manning has done this the last five years.

Answer 4

this is a hard question, because there are many qualities to quarterbacks that make them good. most people can agree that tom brady and peyton manning are both in the top top tier of nfl quarterbacks, but when it comes down to deciding who's better, the question becomes harder. tom brady obviously has had more team success, with 3 super bowls in 4 years. peyton manning undoubtedly has better individual statistics, however. in rebuttal to the manning's stats argument, one could argue that manning has much more talented receivers in harrison, wayne, and clark. this is definitely true, because, especially this year, brady has had to make do with at best average receivers. so, my verdict is this: peyton manning is more skilled as a quarterback, but tom brady is a better leader.

Answer 5

Tom Brady is the best QB of all time...but im also a pats fan, Peyton Manning is one of the best qbs of all time but i dont think he can compare with what tom brady has done..nothing can really compare with his 2001 season and 3 superbowl rings, 2 mvps, dating Giselle Budchen..however you spell her name, and hes going to win at least 2 more superbowls. The patriots are in a great place to improve this offseason with two number 1 picks and a ridiculously talented laurence maroney and plenty of cap room (were going to take cato june from the colts), It would be a miracle if the colts could manage to get to another superbowl with limited cap room, and theyre going to get rid of freeney.

Tom Brady is the best QB of all time..all of you who said hes overrated you dont know anything about football. How can he have 3 rings and 2 superbowl rings and be overrated? but your boy peyton has choked on multiple occasions in the playoffs and only has 1 rings and 1 mvp

Answer 6

Peyton Manning.

Answer 7

Tom Brady because he still has more superbowl rings but stat wise peyton manning is better.

Answer 8

Peyton Manning. I don't care how many rings Brady has, Manning is the ultimate QB, who now has one a Super Bowl. When his career is over, he will be the Jerry Rice of QB's. He will hold 85-90% of all passing records, and will win at least 1 more Super Bowl. Brady's Super Bowl days are over.

Answer 9

Peyton. He has way better stats and he won a Super Bowl. Now you can make the argument that Brady won 3 Super Bowls, but remember, in two of those Super Bowls Vinateiri made the game winning kick. You never know, if Vinateiri had missed those kicks we might not even consider Brady as one of the top QB's in the league.

Answer 10

Peyton Manning!!

Answer 11

Brady is clearly better just look at the stats of when indy played the patriots in the playoffs i forget what it was but it was like 6 Brady 3 manning or somthing. Brady also as more rings.