Who is a bigger cheater?

Question

Barry Bonds -- or -- Mickey Mantle

Please, I beg of you--good answers. I don't want "Bonds sucks he's a dope-head" or anything like that. I want some serious answers from the good baseball fans around here.

Georgie Porgie
Mick7
tkatt00
etc...

That means you.

Answer 1

That's actually a very good question and thanks for picking me as one of the good baseball fans.

Honestly, based on actual hard evidence they'd have to be considered equals.

Both Bonds and Mantle took greenies or amphetamines and that is all the more evidence against either individual. There is plenty of circumstantial evidence surrounding Bonds and his supposed steroid use, but until he actually fails a drug test or is convicted I'd have to say that they are both on the exact same level.

Answer 2

Bonds of course.

Mantle played in an era where performance enhancing drugs were unknown. He may have gambled and drank a lot, but that doesn't help you play. Is there something about Mantle cheating that I don't know? You may have to help me out here.

Bonds, on the other hand, has a ton of circumstantial evidence pointing to him. I know that it isn't definitive, but looking at it realistically if there was no wrong doing nobody would even have brought it up in the first place.

In real life most people don't get accused of wrongdoing unless there is some reason to be suspicious. If suddenly tons of unrelated people start pointing fingers and saying that a person is guilty of something I would tend to believe that there is some reason to look into it and find the truth.

The bottom line is that despite being very unlikeable and a confirmed racist Bonds has not been proven guilty of anything. My personal thought is that like McGwire, and Sosa it seems very strange that a man his age was able to put on so many pounds of lean muscle. It's not natural.

Answer 3

Well, since Mickey Mantle never cheated, I'll have to say the bigger cheater is that sucky dope-head, Bonds

Answer 4

of those 2--- Barry Bonds how can a person build that body mass in a few short years he was real skinny when he playe with the Pirates and look at him know....there was rumors many years ago tha Jose Cardeniel , when he playe for the Cubs that he hid baseballs in the ivy in leftfield or whatever field he was going to play that day.and when we went to the wall to catch the ball that appeared to be above him some how he alway came up with the ball even thought it didn't like he caught it

Answer 5

Bonds because he is closing in on the most revered record in all of baseball.If you read game of shadows it describes what he does and how he cheats.If he is to break Aaron record it will be very shameful and the most looked at record in all of sports will be held by a cheater.Mantle,I don't even know if he cheated.

Answer 6

bonds. definetely. mickey mantle was 100% ture baseball. bonds has been taking drugs for soooo long. he used to be short and skinny. now he's tall and ripped. u do the math

Answer 7

i would say Bonds......... I bet anderson was afraid of bonds getting in trouble so he didnt hold the case...... sorry if this is bad, but, bonds doesnt deserve HOF induction when he retires

Answer 8

umm can i answer?? i am anyway!
i think Bonds because he uses sterioids and says he didnt know that he was. He could have took the 5th like McGuire but he didnt. I say you shouldnt admit to it but atleast take the 5th..not say you didnt know you were taking them, because you knew you were

Answer 9

Bonds, he has no respect for the game. Any athlete who says they didn't know what they were putting into their bodies is a joke..................